Characters played by Caleb Deal
Jason Baldwin
Characters played by Ryan Hammond
Brent Davis
Characters played by Dan Nachtrab
Narrator
Characters played by Tyler J. Neumann
Damien Echols
Characters played by Josh Brandon
Dan Stidham
Characters played by Matthan Harris
Val Price
Characters played by Roger Albelo
Ron LAX
Characters played by Sara Michelle Allen
Rachel Gesier
Characters played by Justin L. Murray
Sergeant Mike Allen
Characters played by Jason Baldwin
Self
Characters played by Damien Wayne Echols
Self
Characters played by Matt Fulcher
Judge David Burnett
Characters played by Jessie Misskelley
Self