Characters played by Gary Gitchell
Self - Former Chief Investigator
West Memphis Police
Characters played by Todd Moore
Self - Parent of Michael Moore
Characters played by Dana Moore
Self - Parent of Michael Moore
Characters played by Pam Hobbs
Self - Mother of Stevie Branch
Characters played by Terry Hobbs
Self - Stepfather of Stevie Branch
Characters played by Melissa Byers
Self - Mother of Christopher Byers
Characters played by John Mark Byers
Self - Stepfather of Christopher Byers
Characters played by Damien Wayne Echols
Self - Perpetrator
Characters played by Jason Baldwin
Self - Perpetrator
Characters played by Jessie Misskelley
Self - Perpetrator
Characters played by John Philipsborn
Self - Post-Conviction Attorney for Jason Baldwin
Characters played by Don Horgan
Self - Post-Conviction Attorney for Damien Echols
Characters played by John N. Fogleman
Self - Prosecuting Attorney
Characters played by Mike Allen
Self - Detective
West Memphis Police
Characters played by Domini Teer
Self - Suspect's Girlfriend
Characters played by Larry Roberts
Self - Neighbor
Characters played by Joni Dwyer
Self - Jason Baldwin's Neighbor
Characters played by Jerry Driver
Self - Former West Memphis Juvenile Officer
Characters played by Diana Davis
Self - KAIT
Characters played by Tony Brooks
Self - KAIT
Characters played by David Steinhart
Self - KAIT
Characters played by Gail Grinnell
Self - Jason Baldwin's Mother
Characters played by Paul Ford
Self - Original Defense Attorney for Jason Baldwin
Characters played by Jessie Misskelley Sr.
Self - Father of Jessie Jr.
Characters played by Dan Stidham
Self - Original Defense Attorney for Jessie Jr.
Characters played by Eddie Vedder
Self
Characters played by Johnny Depp
Self
Characters played by Kathy Bakken
Self - Co-Founder
Free the WM3 Support Fund
Characters played by Grove Pashley
Self - Co-Founder
Free the WM3 Support Fund
Characters played by Burk Sauls
Self - Co-Founder
Free the WM3 Support Fund
Characters played by Rod Starns
Self - Channel 5
Characters played by Dennis Riordan
Self - Post-Conviction Attorney for Damien Echols
Characters played by Werner Spitz
Self - Forensic and Anatomic Pathologist
Characters played by Richard Souviron
Self - Forensic Odontologist
Characters played by Tom Fedor
Self - Forensic Serologist
Characters played by John Douglas
Self - Retired FBI Criminal Profiler
Characters played by Joe Berlinger
Self - Paradise Lost Filmmakers
Characters played by Bruce Sinofsky
Self - Paradise Lost Filmmakers
Characters played by Lorri Davis
Self - Damien Echol's Wife
Characters played by David Burnett
Self - Judge
Characters played by Dale W. Griffis
Self - Prosecution Expert on the Occult
Characters played by Val P. Price
Self - Defense Attorney for Damien Echols
Characters played by Frank Peretti
Self - Forensic Pathologist
State of Arkansas
Characters played by Lloyd Warford
Self - Lawyer
Characters played by Gina Reynolds
Self - Former Law Clerk for Lloyd Warford
Characters played by Capi Peck
Self - Co-Founder Arksansas Take Action
Characters played by Natalie Maines
Self - Lead Singer
Dixie Chicks
Characters played by Jamie Clark Ballard
Self - Neighbor of Stevie Branch
Characters played by Michael Hobbs
Self - Terry Hobbs' Brother
Characters played by Tina Hobbs
Self - Terry Hobbs' Sister-in-Law
Characters played by David Raupp
Self - Senior Assistant Attorney General
Arkansas
Characters played by Darrell Greene
Self - Channel 13 Reporter
Characters played by Scott Ellington
Self - Prosecuting Attorney
2nd Judicial District of Arkansas
Characters played by Will Carter
Self - Channel 8
Characters played by Lance J. Gosnell
Self - UALR Bowen School Audience Member
Characters played by Megyn Kelly
Self
Characters played by David Laser
Self - Judge
Characters played by Mike Ledford
Self
Characters played by Bryn Ridge
Self
Characters played by Joseph D. Webb
Self