Characters played by Dean Cain
Michael
Characters played by Rachel Blanchard
Lauren
Characters played by George Buza
Kris Kringle
Characters played by Barry Flatman
Braxton Bennett
Characters played by Krista Bridges
Dina Smiger
Characters played by Helen Colliander
Lily
Characters played by Dylan Roberts
Charlie
Characters played by A.C. Peterson
Judge Stewart
Characters played by Joe Silvaggio
Barney Gingerbread
Characters played by Mike Petersen
Dr. Evans
Characters played by Katie Messina
Nurse
Characters played by Carson Durven
Bailiff
Characters played by Jessica Booker
Cindy Hooking
Characters played by Dan Abramovici
Young Man
Characters played by Amanda Barker
Receptionist
Characters played by Raeanna Guitard
Elf
Characters played by Daniel Okeefe
Teen Boy