Characters played by Dean Cain
Sheriff Scott Hanson
Characters played by Jud Tylor
Sarah Walker
Characters played by John Savage
Judge Willis
Characters played by Gary Hudson
Robert Nielson
Characters played by Eric Scott Woods
William
Characters played by Bill Lewis
Kris Kringle
Characters played by Jamie McRae
Susan Hanson
Characters played by Cooper Barnes
Deputy Sam Bryant
Characters played by Jodie Sweetin
Beth
Characters played by Seth Menachem
Mark
Characters played by Harry Victor
Jack
Characters played by Nicole Helen
Lisa
Characters played by Joseph Walsh
Mayor Joe Jacobs
Characters played by Roz Witt
Lorraine
Characters played by Barry Jenner
Harry
Characters played by Andy Clemence
Dr. Rogers
Characters played by Madison Fair
Gracy
Characters played by Mel Fair
Kyle
Characters played by Mo Beatty
Dr. Flowers
Characters played by Denise Poole
Betty
Characters played by Benjamin Easterday
P.I. Tyler
Characters played by Emily Harrison
Ashley
Characters played by Cole Sand
Alex
Characters played by Jadon Sand
Cameron
Characters played by Carter Sand
Michael
Characters played by Heidi Fielek
News Reporter
Characters played by Elizabeth Friedman
Mila Holden
Characters played by Laurie Love
Jessica
Characters played by Bunny Levine
Elderly Woman
Characters played by Vincent De Paul
Tony Smithson
Characters played by Kahilan Skiba
Child
Characters played by Chintamani Guggenheim
Michael's Mother
Characters played by Dominic Ross
Stew Stigman
Characters played by Paul Hoeprich
British Newscaster
Characters played by Jessie Alexander
Stunts
Characters played by Richard Anderson
Non Believer
Characters played by Elise Ballard
Mrs. Willis
Characters played by Blanca Blanco
Ana
Spanish News Reporter
Characters played by Patrick Stalinski
Jon Smith
Characters played by Paul David Roberts
Party Guest
Characters played by Bryan Stamp
Courtroom Gallery Defense