Women Behind Bars Characters

Characters played by Ashley Crary

• Narrator

Characters played by Kay Bess

• Narrator

Characters played by Elizabeth Higgs

• Reenactment - Young Deana Fairchild

• Reenactment - Young Denise Holsinger

• Reenactment - Young Roena Ashing

Characters played by Matthew Robinson

• Reenactment - Killer

• Reenactment - Wesley Roberts

• Reenactment - Willy Hawkins

Characters played by Larry Franklin

• Self - Author 'The Rita Nitz Story'

• Self - Rebecca Bivens' Biographer

• 

Characters played by Matt Gryta

• Reporter

• The Buffalo News

• Self - Reporter

• Buffalo News

Characters played by Tom Schulte

• Self - Overland

• Missouri Police

Characters played by Michael Spielmann

• Reenactment - David Heard

• Reenactment - James O'Malley

Characters played by Carl Miles

• Reenactment - Buddy Musso

• Reenactment - Tony D'Aquila

Characters played by Sophia Easley

• Reenactment - Deborah Rolle

• Reenactment - Young Renay Lynch

Characters played by Mary Ellen Fernandez

• Reenactment - Carolyn Joyce Thomas

• Reenactment - Maudeline Bailey

Characters played by Evette Ross

• Reenactment - Renay Lynch

• Reenactment - Sharon Mabry

Characters played by Devon Avery

• Chuck

• Reenactment - Chuck Fleming

Characters played by Serena Orrego

• Reenactment - Delfina Lillelid

• Reenactment - Gena Shaughnessy

Characters played by Nika Blue

• Diane Fleming

• Reenactment - Diane Fleming

Characters played by Jessica Lathem

• Reenactment - Shelby Carano

• Shelby Carano

Characters played by Ashley Watkins

• Reenactment - 'Leslie'

• Reenactment - Lori McLuckie

Characters played by April Heather

• Reenactment - Angela Ferguson

• Reenactment - Jeannie Moore

Characters played by Rose Parker

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 

Characters played by Roena Ashing

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Stacey Lannert

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Noah McKinnon

• Self - Prosecutor

Characters played by Cindy Countess

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Rita Nitz

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Samuel Hargrave

• Self - Sheriff's Department

• 
• 

Characters played by Glenna Edler

• Self - Delpha Spunaugle's Cousin

Characters played by Melody McDonald

• Self - Newspaper Reporter

Characters played by Peggy Hilt

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Kathleen Cannon

• Self - Public Defender

Characters played by Alicia Williamson

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Karen Mullally

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Deborah Rolle

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Shawn Hoffman

• Self - Virginia Beach Police

Characters played by Diane Fleming

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Barbara Peters

• Self - Angela Turner's Godmother

Characters played by Jessica Gentry

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Melba Pearson

• Self - Assistant Prosecutor

• 

Characters played by Dolly Mae Clapp

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Teddy Collingsworth

• Self - Investigator

Characters played by Randy Cauthen

• Self - Former Police Captain

Characters played by Ken Kaminsky

• Self - Broward County Sheriff

• 

Characters played by Dean Duggins

• Self - Attempted Murder Victim

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Mike Daniel

• Self - Bastrop County Sheriff

Characters played by Larry Langley

• Jimself - Seneca Falls Police Dept.

Characters played by Nathan Chambers

• Self - Former Dep. District Attorney

Characters played by Manuel Garcia

• Self - Prosecutor

Characters played by Shirley Nanney

• Self - News Editor

• Carroll County News-Leader

• 

Characters played by Celeste Beard Johnson

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Alana Minton

• Self - Prosecutor

• 

Characters played by Loretta Ralph

• Self - Roena Ashing's Daughter

• 

Characters played by Margie Elliot

• Self - Joellen Johnson's Mother

• 

Characters played by Katherine Schoenig

• Self - Leslie Demeniuk's Mother

Characters played by Marilyn Hutchinson

• Self - Forensic Psychologist

Characters played by Ronald S. Federici

• Self - Neuropsychologist

• Adoption Expert

Characters played by Delpha Spunaugle

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Dave Keller

• Self - Sheriff's Department

• 

Characters played by Jon Brookmyer

• Self - Rita Nitz's Brother

Characters played by Michael Sterling

• Self - Rose Parker's Husband

Characters played by Linda White

• Self - Cindy Countess's Sister

Characters played by Rolando Garcia

• Self - Investigator

• Miami Homicide

• 

Characters played by John Huffine

• Self - Lead Detective

Characters played by George Reres

• Self - Public Defender's Office

• 

Characters played by Angela Turner

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Stephanie Flood

• Self - Deborah Rolle's Sister

Characters played by David Hargett

• Self - Diane Fleming's Current Attorney

Characters played by Anna Hammond

• Self - Thomas Hammond's Sister

Characters played by Willie Kidd

• Self - Alicia Williamson's Brother

Characters played by Luther Clapp

• Self - Dolly Mae Clapp's Brother

Characters played by Sandy Malone

• Self - Jessica Gentry's Aunt & Adoptive Mother

• 

Characters played by Jennifer Duncan

• Self - Former Inmate

• 

Characters played by Denise Holsinger

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Tim Leonard

• Self - Kernersville Police

Characters played by Jay Russell

• Self - Anderson County Sheriff

Characters played by William Allen

• Self - Holly Coomber's Foster Father

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Allen Proctor

• Self - Pasco County Sheriff's Office

Characters played by Loriann Jimenez

• Self - Andrew Vigil's Cousin

• 
• 

Characters played by Walter Smothers

• Self - Murderer

• Deion Smith Harris's Co-Defendant

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Virginia Twenter

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 

Characters played by Kathryn Casey

• Self - Author of 'She Wanted It All'

• 

Characters played by Ellen Flottman

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Patricia Joellen Johnson

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Stacey Snowden

• Self - Art Boga's Niece

• 

Characters played by Robert Drew

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Renee Mulder

• Self - Cindy Countess's Niece

Characters played by Chuck Johnson

• Self - National Council for Adoption

Characters played by Deborah Pieringer

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Thelma Bond

• Self - Delpha Spunaugle's Mother

Characters played by Jeff Connor

• Self - Granite City (IL) Police Dept.

• 
• 

Characters played by Leslie Demeniuk

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by William Fitzpatrick

• Self - Prosecutor

Characters played by Madonna Wallen

• Self - Natasha Cornett's Mother

• 

Characters played by Linda Felcone

• Self - Medical Writer

Characters played by Regina Sanders

• Self - Angela Turner's Friend

• 

Characters played by Angela Kidd

• Self - Alicia Williamson's Sister

Characters played by Gussie Neville

• Self - Dolly Mae Clapp's Friend

Characters played by Michelle Holsinger

• Self - Denise Holsinger's Daughter

• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Lutrische Dancy

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Mary Brown

• Self - Deborah Rolle's Friend

Characters played by Jackie Alexander

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Mary Thornton

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Donna Buchanan

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Teresa Deion Smith Harris

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Jeannie Moore

• Self - Attempted Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Stephanie Batcheller

• Self - Holly Coomber's Current Attorney

Characters played by Kim Bevel

• Self - Melissa Harris's Sister

Characters played by Mitch Morrissey

• Self - District Attorney

Characters played by Elmer Beckworth

• Self - Assistant District Attorney

Characters played by Lorene Allen

• Self - Deborah Pieringer's Aunt

Characters played by Charlie Bosworth

• Self - Former Newspaper Reporter

Characters played by Jeff Mittelhauser

• Self - Prosecutor

Characters played by Laura Eske

• Self - Joellen Johnson's Co-Worker and Friend

Characters played by Michael Houston

• Self - Rose Parker's Nephew

Characters played by Tom Wilson

• Self - Stacey Lannert's High School Boyfriend

Characters played by Jason Spencer

• Self - Newspaper Reporter

Characters played by Carol Muth

• Self - Family Friend

Characters played by Larry Lee Beard

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Ronny Snowder

• Self - Delpha Spunaugle's Cousin

Characters played by Norma Jean Campbell

• Self - Cindy Countess's Sister

Characters played by John Ewing

• Self - Leslie Demeniuk's Father

Characters played by Natasha Wallen Cornett

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Daniel Killelea

• Self - Former Prosecutor

Characters played by Alan Cooper

• Editor

• Self - Reporter

Characters played by Linda Bond

• Self - Robert Atkins

• Jr's Former Wife

• 

Characters played by Barbara Griffin

• Self - Assistant District Attorney

Characters played by Doug McKeown

• Self - Forensic Psychologist

Characters played by Debbie Braswell

• Self - Donna Buchanan's Sister

Characters played by Twink Foggie

• Self - Jackie Alexander's Daughter

• 

Characters played by Paula Drinkwine

• Self - Tracy & Paul Turo's Aunt

Characters played by Joe Cooper

• Self - Lutrische Dancy's Father

• 

Characters played by Lanna Belohlavek

• Self - Prosecutor

Characters played by Randall Holsinger

• Self - Denise Holsinger's Ex-Husband

• 
• 

Characters played by Donna Duggins

• Self - Attempted Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Barbara Sexton

• Self - Bobby Sexton's Mother

• 

Characters played by Holly Coomber

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Melissa Harris

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Jim Chandler

• Self - True Crime Writer

• 

Characters played by Lori McLuckie

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Tom Custer

• Self - Edmond Police

• 

Characters played by Chris McGraugh

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Emzie Parker IV

• Self - Rose Parker's Son

• 

Characters played by Lynne Adkins

• Self - Virginia Twenter's Cousin

• 

Characters played by Marilyn Clifton

• Self - Michael Miley's Sister

• 

Characters played by Patrick Gass

• Self - Crime Scene Analyst

• 

Characters played by Monique Evans

• Self - Nina Hilt's Preschool Teacher

• 

Characters played by Keith Talley

• Self - Retired Fire Captain

Characters played by Donna Cohen

• Self - Professor of Aging and Mental Health

• 

Characters played by Gary Cobb

• Self - Prosecutor

• 
• 

Characters played by Antonio Ortiz

• Self - Leslie Demeniuk's Boyfriend

• 

Characters played by Robert Bryden

• Self - Peter Johnson's Friend

Characters played by Helen Smith

• Self - Forensic Psychologist

• 

Characters played by John Cahill

• Self - Deborah Rolle's Current Husband

Characters played by Harriet Ivey

• Self - Journalist

Characters played by Danise Atkins-Edgecombe

• Self - Robert Atkins

• Jr's Sister

Characters played by Mohammed H. Razavi

• Self - Angela Turner's Friend

• 

Characters played by Greg Miller

• Self - Assistant District Attorney

Characters played by Linda Stout

• Self - Donna Buchanan's Mother

• 

Characters played by Connie Cox

• Self - Diane Fleming's Childhood Friend

Characters played by Paula Jean Drinkwine

• Self - Tracy & Paul Turo's Cousin

Characters played by Sarah Cooper-Jackson

• Self - Lutrische Dancy's Sister

Characters played by Lhan Le Son

• Self - Lam Van Son's Widow

• 
• 

Characters played by Robert Mascari

• Self - First Asst. District Attorney

Characters played by Sammie Bevel

• Self - Melissa Harris's Mother

Characters played by Billy Smith

• Self - Deion Smith Harris's Father

• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Patricia Sexton

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Holly Berrios

• Self - Donna Duggins's Daughter

• 
• 

Characters played by David Lane

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Dick DeGuerin

• Self - Defense Attorney

• 

Characters played by Clay Biddle

• Self - Prosecutor

Characters played by Cathy Wheeler

• Self - Former Bank Teller

• 

Characters played by Matt Hardy

• Self - Lead Investigator

Characters played by Roy Koberna

• Self - Granite City (IL) Police Dept.

• Retired

Characters played by John Buttner

• Self - Sergeant

• Manassas Police

Characters played by Robert Macy

• Self - Retired Prosecutor

Characters played by Stephanie Klein-Davis

• Self - Roanoke Times

Characters played by Sharon Ewing

• Self - Leslie Demeniuk's Stepmother

Characters played by David Negus

• Self - Deputy Public Defender

Characters played by Melanie Knoebel

• Self - Angela Turner's Friend

Characters played by Mike Coursey

• Self - Tarrant County Sheriff

Characters played by Charles Berkeley Bell

• Self - District Attorney General

• 

Characters played by Mawiya Charles

• Self - Lutrische Dancy's Oldest Daughter

• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Fred Susaneck

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Donette Dunnigan

• Self - Diane Fleming's Sister

Characters played by James Atkins

• Self - Robert Atkins

• Jr's Son

• 

Characters played by Helen Stroud

• Self - Jackie Alexander's High School Friend

Characters played by Mary Gugliuzza

• Self - Buffalo Homocide Detective

Characters played by Danielle Drinkwine

• Self - Tracy & Paul Turo's Cousin

Characters played by Theresa Jackson

• Self - Charles Gouveia's Daughter

• 

Characters played by Mike Mather

• Self - Investigative Reporter

Characters played by Bobby Mims

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Ronnie Brewer

• Self - Donna & Jeannie's Brother

Characters played by Wilma Smith

• Self - Deion Smith Harris's Mother

• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Bill Thompson

• Self - Reporter

Characters played by Robert Crowe

• Self - Asst. District Attorney

Characters played by Bob McLuckie

• Self - Lori McLuckie's Brother

• 

Characters played by Tim Burres

• Self - Sheriff's Department

Characters played by Kathleen Oelschlegel

• Self - Detective

• Manassas Police

• 

Characters played by Charles Garnati

• Self - Prosecutor

Characters played by Al Bender

• Self - Prosecutor

Characters played by Alan Howard

• Self - Deputy

Characters played by Terri Figueroa

• Self - Newspaper Reporter

Characters played by Terry Milam

• Self - St. John Police

Characters played by Kenneth Brasfield

• Self - Pharmacological Expert

Characters played by Charolette Aiken

• Self - Newspaper Reporter

Characters played by Lloyd Whelchel

• Self - Prosecutor

Characters played by Linda Turner

• Self - Virginia Twenter's Friend

• 

Characters played by Clyde Boyd

• Self - Deputy District Attorney

Characters played by Gina Stafford

• Self - Reporter

Characters played by Paul Yoakam

• Self - Virginia Beach Police (Retired)

• 

Characters played by Kayla Thomas

• Self - Carolyn Joyce Thomas's Granddaughter

Characters played by Claire Brennan Dunne

• Self - Newspaper Reporter

Characters played by Gena Shaughnessy

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Charlotte Allen

• Self - Thomas Hammond's Sister

• 

Characters played by LaToya Goree

• Self - Mechelle Hicks's God-Daughter

Characters played by Jeffrey Tanner

• Self - Diane Fleming's Son

• 
• 

Characters played by Ken Jobson

• Self - Antoinette 'Toni' Jobson's Father

• 
• 

Characters played by Esther Jacobo

• Self - Former Prosecutor

Characters played by Lenore Walker

• Self - Psychologist

• 

Characters played by Terry Brandon

• Self - Charlotte-Mecklenburg PD

Characters played by Jason Waller

• Self - Smith County Sheriff's Department

• Retired

Characters played by Linda Bingham

• Self - Patricia Sexton's Mother

Characters played by Tim McDonald

• Self - Deion Smith Harris's Husband

• 
• 

Characters played by Lois Sillaman

• Self - Lori McLuckie's Therapist

Characters played by Gene Brewer

• Self - Donna & Jeannie's Father

• 

Characters played by Bennie Moore

• Self - Emily 'Sue' Moore's Husband

• 
• 

Characters played by Tad Dickens

• Self - Newspaper Reporter

Characters played by Eric Schoenig

• Self - Leslie Demeniuk's Stepfather

Characters played by Linus Yurkus

• Self - Deputy Sheriff

• 

Characters played by Carl Keller

• Self - Sheriff's Department

• 

Characters played by Pedram Mansouri

• Self - Attorney at Law

Characters played by Connie Keel

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Colleen Barnett

• Self - Prosecutor

Characters played by John Schupp

• Self - Former Crime Scene Investigator

Characters played by Danny Burns

• Self - Appeals Attorney

Characters played by Chris Box

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Theresa Vargas

• Self - Newspaper Reporter

Characters played by Eunice Cooper

• Self - Sergeant

• Miami Homicide

• 

Characters played by Ruthie Keefner

• Self - Gena Shaughnessy's Sister

Characters played by Robert Remias

• Self - Neighbor

Characters played by Noreen Walsh

• Self - Buffalo Homocide Detective

Characters played by Tom Perkins

• Self - Baldwinsville Fire Dept.

Characters played by John Orr

• Self - Virginia Beach Police

Characters played by Frank Waddell

• Self - Greeneville Sheriff's Department

Characters played by Janice Jobson

• Self - Antoinette 'Toni' Jobson's Mother

• 
• 

Characters played by David Wallace

• Self - Mecklenburg Co. Prosecutor

Characters played by Suzy Thomas

• Self - Carolyn Joyce Thomas's Granddaughter

Characters played by Sue Vogan

• Self - Journnalist

Characters played by Larry Harris

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Evelyn Jackson

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Savannah Harris

• Self - Deion Smith Harris's Daughter

• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Pauline Jimenez

• Self - Andrew Vigil's Aunt

Characters played by Dorothy Bingham

• Self - Patricia Sexton's Grandmother

• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Myra Duato

• Self - Maudeline Bailey's Daughter

• 

Characters played by Laura Moore

• Self - Emily 'Sue' Moore's Daughter

• 
• 

Characters played by Bernice Ahrens

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Mark Thomason

• Self - Defense Attorney

• 

Characters played by Sarah Ovaska

• Self - Newspaper Reporter

Characters played by Barbara LeFleur

• Self - Connie Keel's Stepmother

Characters played by Rockie Yardley

• Self - Edmond Police

Characters played by Jay Lawing

• Self - Sheriff's Department

Characters played by Anne Albers

• Self - Stacey Lannert TrialJuror

Characters played by Judy Wilson

• Self - Deborah Pieringer's Friend

Characters played by Michael Kraynik

• Self - Jennifer Blake's Brother

Characters played by Carrie Hempel

• Self - Professor of Law

• USC

Characters played by Mike Pittman

• Self - Fingerprint Expert

Characters played by David Wexler

• Self - Expert Witness for the Defense

Characters played by David Ovalle

• Self - Reporter

• Miami Herald

Characters played by Vanessa Crawley

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Mohammed Ali Al-Bayati

• Self - Toxicologist and Pathologist

• 

Characters played by Stacy Street

• Self - Defense Attorney

• 

Characters played by Patricia Donnelly

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Edward Rose

• Self - Charles Gouveia's Grandson

• 

Characters played by Eugene Conway

• Self - Lead Investigator

Characters played by Denise Streff

• Self - Assistant Public Defender

Characters played by Celeste Mallory

• Self - Mechelle Hicks's Best Friend

Characters played by Mark Speas

• Self - Cabarrus County District Attorney

Characters played by David Atwell

• Self - Prosecutor

Characters played by Randy Loboda

• Self - Dallas Police Department

Characters played by Marsha Moore Harding

• Self - Emily 'Sue' Moore's Daughter

• 

Characters played by Tom DiFiori

• Self - Calumet City Police

Characters played by Joel Brown

• Self - Northglenn Police Dept.

Characters played by Robert Attridge

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by James 'Buddy' Bingham

• Self - Patricia Sexton's Grandfather

Characters played by Mary Ann Hart

• Self - Andrew Vigil's Foster Mother

Characters played by Maryann Acker

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Ruth Rendon

• Self - Newspaper Reporter

• 

Characters played by Cyndi Prudden

• Self - Prison Superintendent

Characters played by Dan Engel

• Self - Chicago Police

Characters played by John Augustine

• Self - Riverside Police

• Retired

Characters played by Scott Beaver

• Self - Lead Investigator

Characters played by Clarence LeFleur

• Self - Connie Keel's Father

Characters played by Glenn Schubert

• Self - Forensic Scientist

• 

Characters played by Rebecca Bivens

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Ellen Harris

• Self - Journalist

• 

Characters played by Paul Hedges

• Attorney

• Self - Family Friend

Characters played by Ernest Miller

• Self - Psychiatrist

Characters played by Derek Wilkes

• Self - Jackie Alexander's Co-Conspirator

• 

Characters played by Sheldon Zipkin

• Self - Defense Attorney

• 

Characters played by Joseph Ruhlin

• Self - Lead Detective

• 
• 

Characters played by Betty Rickmond

• Self - Diane Fleming's Friend

Characters played by Roy Lee Johnson

• Self - Vanessa Crawley's Father

• 
• 

Characters played by Dan Stauffer

• Self - Fire Investigator

Characters played by Raleigh McGee

• Self - Gena Shaughnessy's Father

Characters played by Nancy Mulder

• Self - Assistant District Attorney

Characters played by Michael DeVita

• Self - Broward County Sheriff

Characters played by Andrew LoTempio

• Self - Dolly Mae Clapp's Defense Attorney

Characters played by Jason Donnelly

• Self - Patricia Donnelly's Ex-Husband

• 
• 

Characters played by Donald Valenza

• Self - Deputy Chief

• Sheriff's Dept.

Characters played by Bill Hall

• Self - Fort Pierce Police Dept.

Characters played by Mary Taft

• Self - Donna Guerriri's Mother

Characters played by Cynthia Kowert

• Self - Assistant District Attorney

Characters played by Amanda Harris

• Self - Melissa Harris's Daughter

• 

Characters played by Brad Shannon

• Self - El Paso County Sheriff

Characters played by Debbie Boyd

• Self - Evelyn Jackson's Mother

Characters played by Richard Prior

• Self - Newspaper Reporter

Characters played by Diane Hamill Metzger

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Martin Abrams

• Self - Defense Attorney

• 

Characters played by Al Becker

• Self - Buddy Musso's Friend

Characters played by Mary Condon

• Self - Connie Keel's Former Sister-in-Law

• 

Characters played by Linda Spalding

• Self - Maryann Acker's Biographer

• 
• 

Characters played by R.J. Larizza

• Self - Former Asst. Prosecutor

Characters played by Clifford Harper

• Self - Homicide Detective

Characters played by Jennifer Blake

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Ray Rickert

• Self - Pastor

• 

Characters played by Patrick Camden

• Self - Media Relations

• Chicago PD

Characters played by Katie Newsham

• Self - Tony D'Aquila's Lawyer and Friend

Characters played by Glenn Bukata

• Self - Broward County Sheriff

Characters played by LaSonya Larry

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Cathy Barbour

• Self - Diane Fleming's Friend

Characters played by Chris Crawley

• Self - Vanessa Crawley's Husband

• 
• 

Characters played by Barrett Richardson

• Self - Heather Frango's Defense Attorney

Characters played by Greg Hatley

• Family Friend

• Self - Boxing Coach

Characters played by Ouida Heath

• Self - Patricia Donnelly's Ex Mother-in-Law

Characters played by Michael Casey

• Self - Detective

• Melbourne Police

Characters played by Michael Mordino

• Self - Buffalo Homocide Detective

Characters played by Anthony Giordano

• Self - Appeals Attorney

Characters played by Dolores Barrett

• Self - Gena Shaughnessy's Neighbor

Characters played by Donovan Arias

• Self - Investigator

• Sheriff's Dept.

• 

Characters played by Paul Gesi

• Self - Northglenn Police Dept.

Characters played by Rudine Hills

• Self - Thomas Noble's Girlfriend

• 
• 

Characters played by John Suthers

• Self - Attorney General of Colorado

Characters played by Al Covington

• Self - Lois Thomas' Friend

Characters played by Brian Hubbs

• Self - Seneca County Sheriff's Dept.

Characters played by Alan Cohen

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Deana Fairchild

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Denise Bradley

• Self - Prosecutor

• 

Characters played by Eunice Hamill

• Self - Diane Metzger's Mother

• 
• 

Characters played by Michael Brennan

• Self - Appeals Attorney

• 

Characters played by Carmen Ortiz

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Frank Gildea

• Self - Prosecutor

Characters played by James Freeze

• Self - Morgan Hill (CA) Police Dept.

• Retired

• 

Characters played by Jeffrey Stone

• Self - Homicide Detective

• 

Characters played by Kathleen Heide

• Self - Professor of Criminology

Characters played by Steve Greenberg

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Gary Beatty

• Self - Assistant Prosecutor

Characters played by Whitney Johnson

• Self - Vanessa Crawley's Sister

• 
• 

Characters played by Nancy B.B. Meyer

• Self - Dennis Titus's Friend

Characters played by Cindy Lewis

• Self - Angela Turner Trial Juror

• 

Characters played by John Hamptom Read

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Heather Disney

• Self - Patricia Donnelly's Former Neighbor

Characters played by David Shapiro

• Self - Psychologist

Characters played by Belle Turner

• Self - LaSonya Larry's Cousin

• 

Characters played by Beth Miner

• Self - Assistant Public Defender

Characters played by Alice Connor

• Self - Heather Frango's Cousin

• 
• 
• 

Characters played by William Coltrain

• Self - Shelby Carano's Friend

Characters played by Michael Acquino

• Self - Buffalo Homocide Detective

Characters played by Tammie Anderson

• Self - Jennifer Freels' Former Sister-in-Law

• 

Characters played by Dinah Moore

• Self - Emily 'Sue' Moore's Daughter

• 

Characters played by Erica Whitehead

• Self - Lois Thomas' Co-Worker

• 

Characters played by Teresa Roever

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Angela Rocka

• Self - Convict

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Sarah Prohaska

• Self - Reporter

• Palm Beach Post

Characters played by Susan D'Aquila

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Celeste Fox

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 

Characters played by John Hopkins

• Self - Newspaper Reporter

• 

Characters played by Mike Gordon

• Self - Newspaper Reporter

• 

Characters played by Evelyn Ortiz

• Self - Carmen Ortiz's Sister

• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Floyd Jennings

• Self - Clinical Psychologist

Characters played by Bill McClellan

• Self - Newspaper Columnist

Characters played by Frann Stafford

• Self - Diane Metzger's Classmate

Characters played by Elysia Keel

• Self - Connie Keel's Daughter

• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Mathew Fairchild

• Self - Deana Fairchild's Son

• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Chanel Boyd

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Mike James

• Self - Former State's Attorney

Characters played by Steven C. Ippolito

• Self - NY Parole (Retired)

Characters played by Dwight Thompson

• Self - Shelby Carano's Father

Characters played by Donna Fielder

• Self - Denton Record Chronicle

Characters played by Alberta Stapleton

• Self - Anita Gonzales's Mother

• 

Characters played by Holly Hunter

• Self - Chemical Dependency Counselor

Characters played by Tom Cepeda

• Self - Chicago Police Department

Characters played by Radisha Jefferson

• Self - Vanessa Crawley's Sister

• 

Characters played by Randell Alexander

• Self - Professor of Pediatrics

Characters played by Shaniqua Brown

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by James Martin

• Heather Frango's Boyfriend

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Stephanie Battle

• Self - LaSonya Larry's Childhood Friend

Characters played by Brian DeLaFranier

• Self - Linda Pillius's Former Fiancé

• 

Characters played by Kevin Cunningham

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by John Jordan

• Self - Prosecutor

Characters played by Russell Maffet

• Self - Jennifer Freels' Ex-Husband

• 
• 

Characters played by Chaya Katz

• Self - Louise Cicelsky's Daughter

Characters played by Steve Gosnell

• Self - Assistant State Attorney

Characters played by Tammie Harris

• Self - Teresa Roever's Daughter

• 
• 

Characters played by Janis Lewis

• Self - Chanel Boyd's Aunt

Characters played by John Krasnican

• Self - Investigator

Characters played by Ginger Corey

• Self - Susan D'Aquila's Sister

Characters played by Robert Pruett

• Self - Chief of Police

Characters played by Walter Schweinfurths

• Self - Neighbor

Characters played by Jose Gomez

• Self - Chicago Police

• 

Characters played by Don Fudo

• Self - Appellate Prosecutor

Characters played by Jame Darst

• Self - Prosecuting Attorney

Characters played by Danny Fox

• Self - Celeste Fox's Uncle

• 

Characters played by Coleen Plyler

• Self - Metzger Family Neighbor

Characters played by Jim Kennedy

• Self - NYPD Homicide Detective (Retired)

Characters played by Judith Kinney

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Otis Taylor

• Self - Kerry Taylor's Brother

Characters played by Sheila Lathrop

• Self - Shelby Carano's Mother

Characters played by Keith Davis

• Self - Live Oak Police Department

• 

Characters played by Michael Hughes

• Self - Chicago Police Department

Characters played by Susan Walton

• Self - Prosecutor

Characters played by Linda Pillius

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Alex Grimsley

• Self - LaSonya Larry's Ex-Boyfriend

Characters played by Sharon Mabry

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Terry Edmonds

• Self - Mecklenburg County

Characters played by Keelronn Hatley

• Self - Family Friend

Characters played by Harold Umanzor

• Self - Angela Rocka's Co-Defendant

• 

Characters played by Dennis Sladek

• Self - Teresa Roever's Attoreny

Characters played by Rinaldo Moss

• Self - Renay Lynch's Son

• 

Characters played by Doronna Konrath

• Self - Jennifer Freels' Neighbor

Characters played by Wesley Roberts

• Self - Willie Mae Hampton's Nephew

• 
• 

Characters played by Anne Marie Gennusa

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Maribel Rivera

• Self - Carmen Ortiz's Friend

Characters played by Rachel Smith

• Self - Chief Prosecutor

Characters played by Ed Weiss

• Self - Prosecutor

Characters played by Victoria Ewell

• Self - Susan D'Aquila's Daughter

• 

Characters played by Steve Hioki

• Self - Defense Attorney

• 

Characters played by Phil Presse

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Dana Treen

• Self - Newspaper Reporter

Characters played by Frank Madea

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Sharon Davis-Gibson

• Self - Executive Director Dani-Brandon Center

• 
• 

Characters played by Jamie C. Ruff

• Self - Richmond Times - Dispatch

• 

Characters played by Shelby Carano

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Catherine Wagner

• Self - Prosecutor

• 

Characters played by Marion Faye Cason

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by John Moeser

• Self - NYPD Detective (Retired)

Characters played by Foy Taylor

• Self - Kerry Taylor's Father

Characters played by Tylisha Brown

• Self - Shaniqua Brown's Sister

• 

Characters played by Robert Barnes

• Self - LaSonya Larry's Friend

• 

Characters played by John Jones

• Self - Investigator

Characters played by Robin Alderman

• Self - Sean Wagner's Mother

• 
• 

Characters played by Adam Katz

• Self - Chicago Police Department

Characters played by Charles Hatley

• Self - Family Friend

Characters played by Rhoda Pilmer

• Self - Assistant District Attorney

Characters played by William Muñoz

• Self - Houston Police Department

• 

Characters played by Joseph LaCorte

• Self - Amherst Police Dept.

Characters played by Brian Mallonee

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Jane Turner

• Self - Assistant Medical Examiner

Characters played by Eugene Gallagher

• Self - Tony D'Aquila's Former Employer

Characters played by Robert Chapman

• Self - Psychiatrist for the Defense

• 

Characters played by Betsy Kastak

• Self - Nurse Practitioner

• Mount Sinai Hospital

Characters played by Robert Gober

• Self - Sheriff's Department

• 

Characters played by Jasmin Alvarez

• Self - Carmen Ortiz's Daughter

• 
• 

Characters played by Barbara Ormsby

• Self - Reporter

Characters played by Herb Zieglmeier

• Self - Celestine Fox's Neighbor

Characters played by Aneisha Munsey

• Self - Anita Gonzales's Co-Defendant

• 
• 

Characters played by Michele McPhee

• Self - True Crime Author

Characters played by Ernest M. Page

• Self - Assistant State Attorney

Characters played by Marilyn Prosper

• Self - Witness

Characters played by Pamela Leeming

• Self - Assistant Public Defender

Characters played by Daniel Titus

• Self - Dennis Titus's Brother

Characters played by Arnita Fiason

• Self - Sharon Mabry's Mother

• 

Characters played by Terry Stewart

• Self - Denton Police Department

Characters played by Janelle Larry

• Self - LaSonya Larry's Daughter

• 

Characters played by Danny Fox

• Self - Sheriff

• Mecklenburg County

Characters played by Tamara Dietrich

• Self - Newspaper Columnist

• 

Characters played by Renay Lynch

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Jo Ann Zuñiga

• Self - Former Reporter

• Houston Chronicle

Characters played by Dan Churney

• Self - Newspaper Reporter

Characters played by Michael B. Bolan

• Self - Retired Judge

Characters played by Aviva Futorian

• Self - Clemency Attorney

Characters played by Art Donato

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Larry Brazile

• Self - Fire Marshal

• 

Characters played by Susan Decker

• Self - Former Reporter

• Florida Today

Characters played by Andrew Copertino

• Self - NYPD Detective (Retired)

• 

Characters played by Shawn Edwards

• Self - Monroe Co. Sheriff's Dept.

Characters played by Cathy Strouse

• Self - Virginia Animal Control

Characters played by Vincent Ray

• Self - LaSonya Larry's Neighbor

Characters played by John Greenbacker

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by William Cason

• Self - Marion Faye Cason's Father

Characters played by Paul Johnson

• Self - Defense Attorney

Characters played by Julie Rendelman

• Self - Prosecutor

Characters played by Deborah Royal

• Self - Renay Lynch's Sister

Characters played by Ronald Phillips

• Self - Harris County Sheriff's Office

• Retired

Characters played by Robin Strickler

• Self - Prosecutor

Characters played by Robert Myers

• Self - Chicago Police

• 

Characters played by Tim Cappellini

• Self - Public Defender

Characters played by Dave Hamill

• Self - Diane Metzger's Brother

• 

Characters played by Rex Blake

• Self - Prosecutor

Characters played by Randy Riesdorph

• Self - Victim's Son

• 
• 

Characters played by David Vaughn

• Self - Lead Investigator

Characters played by Lois Sims

• Self - Juror

Characters played by David Cohen

• Self - Defense Attorney

• 

Characters played by Sabine Hirschauer

• Self - Reporter

Characters played by Angelia Cason

• Self - Marion Faye Cason's Mother

Characters played by Judy Lynch

• Self - Renay Lynch's Sister

Characters played by Ernie Preate Jr.

• Self - Former PA Attorney General

Characters played by David Delgado

• Self - Circuit Court Judge

• 

Characters played by Shauna Tyre

• Self - Marion Faye Cason's Aunt

Characters played by Raymond Moss

• Self - Renay Lynch's Former Boyfriend

• 

Characters played by Colleen Shotzberger

• Self - Diane Metzger's Boss

Characters played by Willa Smart

• Self - Marion Faye Cason's Grandmother

Characters played by Tim McGrath

• Self - Forensic Psychiatrist

Characters played by Joy Brunson

• Reenactment - Rose Parker

Characters played by Michelle Tomlinson

• Reenactment - Virginia Twenter

Characters played by Ashley Reign

• Reenactment - Celeste Fox

Characters played by David Pearl

• Reenactment - Judge David Delgado

Characters played by Turna Mete

• Reenactment - Diane Metzger

Characters played by Paul Galazo

• Reenactment - Antonio Ortiz

Characters played by Andy Cramer

• Reenactment - Thomas Bauer

Characters played by Drue Delio

• Reenactment - Edwin Woodward

Characters played by Setareh

• Reenactment - Carmen Ortiz

Characters played by K.C. White

• Reenactment - Roena Ashing

Characters played by Verity Butler

• Reenactment - Martha 'Marti' Metzger

Characters played by Jordana Johns

• Reenactment - Evelyn Ortiz

Characters played by Dj Rouse

• Reenactment - Dennis Spunaugle

Characters played by Samantha Yonack

• Reenactment - Rita Nitz

Characters played by Trevor Blanding

• Reenactment - Jeff Ramsey

Characters played by Nathan Johnson

• Reenactment - Art Boga

Characters played by Dan Churney

• Self - newspaper reporter

Characters played by Kirstin Sarfde

• Reenactment - Cindy Countess

Characters played by Phil Gibson

• Self - Defense Attorney

• 

Characters played by Brian Stewart

• Reenactment - Tommy Demeniuk

Characters played by Amy Snively

• Reenactment - Delpha Spunaugle

Characters played by Toni Grafton

• Reenactment - Connie Keel

Characters played by Dana Mirrison

• Reenactment - Edna Dooley

Characters played by Tanya Frank

• Reenactment - Tina

Characters played by Brandon Bally

• Reenactment - Police Officer

Characters played by Ashley House

• Reenactment - Chanel Boyd

Characters played by Robert Koenig

• Reenactment - Steven Beard

Characters played by Darren James

• Self - Drug Dealer

Characters played by Howard Smart

• Reenactment - Frank Metzger

Characters played by Martine Holden

• Reenactment - Deana Fairchild

Characters played by Aaron 'Ace' Smith

• Reenactment - Jermaine Mullen

Characters played by Marilyn Schweinfurths

• Self - Neighbor

Characters played by Sheenalee Vint

• Reenactment - Susan D'Aquila

Characters played by Elizabeth Welker

• Reenactment - Celeste Beard

Characters played by Carlo Janene Wyatt

• Reenactment - Celestine Fox

Characters played by La-Chic

• Reenactment - Chanel Boyd's Grandmother

Characters played by William Herr

• Reenactment - John D. Wells

Characters played by Anita Gallup

• Reenactment - Suzanne Basso

Characters played by Anthony Osegiera

• Reenactment - Mathew Fairchild

Characters played by Ryan Graves

• Reenactment - Richard Nitz

Characters played by Claudette Honda

• Reenactment - Bernice Ahrens

Characters played by Brian Kehoe

• Reenactment - Michael Miley

Characters played by Brad Battles

• Reenactment - John McIntire

Characters played by Bill Durham

• Reenactment - James Johns

• Sr.

Characters played by Jay Charlesworth

• Reenactment - Joe Martin

Characters played by Dana Nielle

• Reenactment - Kathy Kraynik

Characters played by Matthew Moran

• Reenactment - Oswaldo Gonzalez

Characters played by Albert Lyras

• Reenactment - Richie Loftis

Characters played by April Hale

• Reenactment - Alicia Williamson

Characters played by McCready Baker

• Reenactment - Denise Holsinger

Characters played by Eric Mbanda

• Reenactment - Derek Wilkes

• 

Characters played by Greg Andrews

• Reenactment - Larvonrick Williams

Characters played by Nathan Sikes

• Reenactment - Allen Aganovic

Characters played by Mitchell McCurdy

• Reenactment - Jason Blake Bryant

Characters played by Yirtuanlak Fentaw

• Reenactment - Anthony O'Garro

• 

Characters played by Lindsay Welliver

• Reenactment - Heather Frango

Characters played by Jessica Boyd

• Reenactment - Lisa Dickerson

Characters played by Sarah Collette Campbell

• Reenactment - Linda Pillius

Characters played by Brittany Bostick

• Reenactment - Young Anita Ruth Gonzales

Characters played by Carol McCright

• Reenactment - Donna Riesdorph

Characters played by Matthew L. Sobel

• Reenactment - James Gusich

Characters played by Jeanette Hacker

• Reenactment - Vanessa Crawley

Characters played by Heather Frango

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Lindsay Collins

• Reenactment - Anita Ruth Gonzales

Characters played by Alan Michael Woods

• Reenactment - Drew Alexander

Characters played by Brandy Hume

• Reenactment - Young LaSonya Nadine Larry

Characters played by Patrice Bone

• Reenactment - Lutrische Dancy

Characters played by Cheryl Jackson

• Reenactment - Shawana Moss

Characters played by Thomas Fraser

• Reenactment - Thomas Hammond

Characters played by Fariba Skobin

• Reenactment - Prostitute 3

Characters played by Gretchen Keels

• Reenactment - Prostitute 2

Characters played by Max Braun

• Reenactment - Dennis Titus

Characters played by Kris McKee

• Reenactment - Charles Gouveia

Characters played by Melissa Mack

• Reenactment - Shannon Buard

Characters played by Thomas Hammond

• Self - Murder Victim

• 

Characters played by Carina Doyle

• Reenactment - Antoinette Marie Jobson

Characters played by Emma Loudenback

• Reenactment - Karen Renea Howell

Characters played by Christine Degroh

• Reenactment - Karen Mullally

Characters played by Herbert Grisby

• Reenactment - Antoine Belton

Characters played by Brandi L. Evans

• Reenactment - Jessica Leanne Gentry

Characters played by Evan Davis

• Reenactment - James Atkins

Characters played by Ted Belcher

• Reenactment - Richard Shaughnessy

Characters played by Alta Duong

• Reenactment - Jian Lin-Chun

Characters played by Elizabeth Zambrano

• Reenactment - Donna Buchanan

Characters played by Robert Young

• Stanley

Characters played by Ian Brown

• Reenactment - Jason Donnelly

Characters played by Barbara Urich

• Reenactment - Detective

Characters played by John Thomas

• Reenactment - Walter Dancy

Characters played by Jared McGee

• Reenactment - Walter Dancy's Son

Characters played by Corey Scott

• Reenactment - Lester Earl Boyd

Characters played by Andrew Witmer

• Reenactment - James Frango

Characters played by Charles E. Armstead

• Reenactment - Walter Dancy's Son

Characters played by Avise Parsons

• Reenactment - Shaniqua Brown

Characters played by Tari Gaffney

• Reenactment - Patricia Donnelly

Characters played by Mary Wilson

• Reenactment - Angela Turner

Characters played by Sandra Renee Glass

• Reenactment - LaSonya Nadine Larry

Characters played by Bryant Babbitt

• Reenactment - Shawn Barclay

Characters played by Russell Williams

• Reenactment - David Shane Tait

Characters played by Annette Jordan

• Reenactment - Young Jackie Alexander

Characters played by Jennifer Clarke

• Reenactment - Dolly Mae Clapp

Characters played by Shirri Ndiforchu

• Reenactment - Mechelle Hicks

• 

Characters played by Fredrick Stegall

• Marion Faye Cason's Roommate

• Self - Murderer

• 

Characters played by Michael Hoag

• Reenactment - Randall Holsinger

Characters played by Anthony Ferreri

• Reenactment - Joseph Lance Risner

Characters played by Barry Isa

• Reenactment - Antoine O'Garro

• 

Characters played by Anthony Leslie

• Reenactment - Michael Wade

Characters played by Ashley Price

• Reenactment - Marion Faye Cason

Characters played by Desarae Flowers

• Reenactment - Young Lutrische Dancy

Characters played by Pamela Lewis

• Reenactment - Jackie Alexander

Characters played by Linnea Dahl

• Reenactment - Denise Holsinger at 25

Characters played by Clay Yates

• Reenactment - Robert Atkins

• Jr.

Characters played by Roy Kalmbacher

• Reenactment - Edward 'Teddy' Riesdorph

Characters played by Lindsey Gibson

• Reenactment - Aneisha Lynn Munsey

Characters played by Nathan Burkart

• Reenactment - Michael Clagett

Characters played by Kirinda Morehead

• Reenactment - Sherred 'Rat' Burney

Characters played by Aaron Smith

• Reenactment - Chris Crawley

Characters played by Joy Hernandez

• Reenactment - Young Sharon Mabry

Characters played by Frances Ogebe

• Reenactment - Willie Kidd

Characters played by Greg Lupu

• Reenactment - Police Officer

Characters played by Rachael Rosenberg

• Reenactment - Natasha Wallen Cornett

Characters played by Trina O'Bryant

• Reenactment - Celeste Mallory

Characters played by Joe Williams

• Reenactment - Timon Black

Characters played by Ben Rucker

• Reenactment - Vidar Lillelid

Characters played by Erik Lund

• Reenactment - Police Officer

Characters played by Alexandra Swarens

• Reenactment - Young Angela Fay Rocka

Characters played by Michael Hanson

• Reenactment - Dean Harris

Characters played by Brittany Mayti

• Reenactment - Kathryn Amos

Characters played by Aleksandr Bible

• Reenactment - William Allen

Characters played by Kieron Elliott

• Howard

Characters played by Michelle Crane

• Reenactment - Donna Duggins

Characters played by Travis Goodman

• Reenactment - Walter Smothers

Characters played by Ana Valverde

• Reenactment - Angela Fay Rocka

Characters played by Adam Dubowsky

• Reenactment - Michael Fielding

Characters played by Joe Casino

• Murder Victim

Characters played by Felicia Dillon

• Reenactment - Young Willie Mae Hampton

Characters played by Bolen Miller

• Reenactment - Bobby Sexton

Characters played by Morgan Dawson

• Reenactment - Young Teresa Roever

Characters played by Daniela Castellanos

• Reenactment - Young Melissa Ann Harris

Characters played by Michael J. Deuschel

• Reenactment - Dr. Luis S. Valdes-Fuerte

Characters played by Chris Oneliner

• Reenactment - Stacy Ramsey

Characters played by Harold Christian Roche

• Ervin Powell

Characters played by Michele Wolding

• Reenactment - Melissa Ann Harris

Characters played by R. Michael David

• Reenactment - Eddie Morgan

Characters played by Jacob Brookfield

• Reenactment - Earl Linebaugh

Characters played by Courtenay Savage

• Self - Murderer

Characters played by Dawn Amos

• Self - Murderer

Characters played by Sirelle Wilkerson

• Reenactment - Rudine Hills

Characters played by Richard Stevenson

• Reenactment - Detective

Characters played by Gwen Hendricks

• Self - Murderer

Characters played by Steve Monvoisin

• Detective

Characters played by Debo Rah Sullivan

• Nancy

Characters played by Dave Marley

• David Spain

Characters played by Danica Seager

• Reenactment - Young Jennifer Freels

Characters played by Gypsy Deveau

• Reenactment - Teresa Deion Smith Harris

Characters played by Jenn Morrison

• Reenactment - Teen Melissa Ann Harris

Characters played by Michael J. Schroder

• Douglas Winter

Characters played by Chad Greendale

• Reenactment - Randy Roever

Characters played by Edina Meiners

• Reenactment - Dawn Amos

Characters played by Jennifer Freels

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Sergio Rodriguez

• Reenactment - Officer William Muñoz

Characters played by Alice Knestaut

• Self - Murderer

Characters played by Doug Newman

• Reenactment - Dean Duggins

Characters played by Jocelyn

• [no data]

Characters played by Marie Robertson

• Reenactment - June Walker

Characters played by Claire Minor

• Reenactment - Willie Mae Hampton

Characters played by Dashun Nelson

• Reenactment - Thomas Noble

Characters played by Willie Mae Hampton

• Self - Murderer

• 
• 
• 
• 

Characters played by Karen Jefferson

• Reenactment - Teresa Roever

Characters played by Abbey Porter

• Reenactment - Young Dawn Amos

Characters played by Helen Shreves

• Self - Murderer

Characters played by Rich Marks

• Larry

Characters played by Angela Ferguson

• Self - Murderer

Characters played by Jocelyn Cantu

• Self - Murderer

Characters played by Allison Bennett

• Reenactment - Patricia Sexton

Characters played by Douglas Biel

• Reenactment - Earl Linebaugh

Characters played by Telma Ramirez

• Reenactment - Cleo Lipkins

Characters played by Jarrell Wingfield

• Reenactment - Harold Umanzor

Characters played by Lourdes Valdes-Fuerte

• Self - Murderer

Characters played by Noelle Vanatta

• Reenactment - Holly Coomber

Characters played by Tim Seager

• Reenactment - Roger Freels

Characters played by Lorri Worley

• Self - Murderer

Characters played by June F. Avilez

• Reenactment - Alice Durfee

Characters played by Jesse Lindell

• Reenactment - Linda Bingham

Characters played by Rhett Bartlett

• Reenactment - Willie Wright

Characters played by Alona Peppers

• Reenactment - Mary Ann Arnold

Characters played by Elizabeth Ruiz

• Twilite

Characters played by Nicole Coelho-Seager

• Reenactment - Jennifer Freels

Characters played by Diana Vehuni

• Reenactment - Lourdes Valdes-Fuerte

Characters played by Roxie Hosseini

• Reenactment - Teen Helen Shreves

Characters played by Bernadette Scully

• Reenactment - Helen Shreves

Characters played by Skarlett Hill

• Reenactment - Lois 'Lolo' Thomas

Characters played by Jennifer Latham

• Self - Murderer

Characters played by Samantha Gude

• Reenactment - Evelyn Jackson

Characters played by Virginia Warden

• Self - Murderer

Characters played by Shawn Briscoe Jr.

• Reenactment - Patrick Williams

Characters played by Sarah Allen

• Self - Murderer

Characters played by Christine Monet

• Reenactment - Tiffany Parsonson

Characters played by Julian Monterrey

• Reenactment - Kerry Taylor

Characters played by Tony Aaron II

• Reenactment - Dolly Mae Clapp's Accomplice

Characters played by Katie Mae Peters

• Mothers in Hospital

Characters played by Timothy Olds

• Father