Characters played by Michael Zuccola
David Whitmer
Characters played by Caleb J. Spivak
Oliver Cowdery
Characters played by Lincoln Hoppe
Martin Harris
Characters played by Paul Wuthrich
Joseph Smith Jr.
Characters played by Jill Adler
Lucy Harris Friend #1
Characters played by Jack Agnew
Messenger
Characters played by Herbie Aitken
Silas' Friend
Characters played by Austen Alexander
Silas
Characters played by Geoffrey Allen
Bishop
Characters played by Mateo Philip Arnold
Mormon
Characters played by Dalton Baker
Samuel Smith
Characters played by Spencer Barber
Christian Whitmer
Characters played by Emerson Beckham
Baseball Boy
Characters played by Joel Bishop
Joseph Smith
Sr.
Characters played by Charla Bocchicchio
Mary Whitmer
Characters played by Jane Bradley
Lucy Harris Friend #3
Characters played by Lily Brady
Harris Child #2
Characters played by Stephanie Breinholt
Lucy Mack Smith
Characters played by Mike Brown
Harmony Attacker #1
Characters played by Peter Brownlee
Mormon
Characters played by Byron Brydges
Pistol Waving Man
Characters played by Connor Burt
Harris Child #4
Characters played by Pat Cannon
Harmony Attacker #2
Characters played by Joseph Carlson
Sidney Rigdon
Characters played by Ted Charette
Edwin Kelly
Characters played by Nicholas Chieffo
Attacker #1
Characters played by Scott Christopher
Peter Whitmer
Sr.
Characters played by Jason Clarke
Faithful Man #2
Characters played by James Connally
Iowa Man
Characters played by Arthur Cummins
Don Carlos Smith
Characters played by Ken Curtis
Hooligan #5
Characters played by Mark Dancewicz
Orson Hyde
Characters played by Dennis Daniel
Crowd
Characters played by Mason D. Davis
Hyrum Smith
Characters played by Skyler M. Day
Woman in Kitchen
Characters played by Zenek de Savigny
David Whitmer
Jr. (5 years old)
Characters played by Ryan Echlin
Hooligan #4
Characters played by Aaron Fielding
Treasure Man #1
Characters played by Cam Findley
William Smith
Characters played by Dan Fowlkes
Hooligan #1
Characters played by Camrey Bagley Fox
Emma Smith
Characters played by Jason Gaignard
Stephen Burnett
Characters played by Craig Gregersen
Faithful Man #1
Characters played by Morgan Gunter
Newell Knight
Characters played by Jason Harley
Warren Parrish
Characters played by Levi Judson Harris
Heber C. Kimball
Characters played by Seven Harrison
Townsperson
Characters played by Lacy Hartselle
Julia Whitmer
Characters played by Addyson Hawk
Maria Cowdery
Characters played by Scarlett Hazen
Lucy Smith
Characters played by Landon Henneman
Defense Attorney
Characters played by William Joseph Holtby
Parley Pratt
Characters played by Zac Hursch
Hooligan #2
Characters played by Zach Hursh
Hooligan #2
Characters played by Tony Ionno
Mormon
Characters played by Danny James
Mob Leader
Characters played by Paul Kandarian
David Whitmer (older)
Characters played by Mark Koufos
Peter Whitmer
Jr.
Characters played by Bennett Langdon
Teen Boy
Characters played by Jared Larkin
Witness #1
Characters played by Tanner Lush
Printer Mob Ruffian
Characters played by Tanner Lush
Printer Mob Ruffian
Characters played by Eb Madson
David Holbrook
Characters played by Louise Mara
Waitress
Characters played by William McAllister
Martin Harris Neighbor #3
Characters played by Dallin McKay
William Smith
Characters played by Matt McLaughlin
Dissident
Characters played by Chipper Meyer
Martin Harris Neighbor #4
Characters played by Korbin Middleton
Baseball Boy
Characters played by Skylar Neale
Andy's Friend
Characters played by Gemma Nye
Harris Child #3
Characters played by Karldon Okruta
Frederick G. Williams
Characters played by Catherine Olsen
Townspeople
Characters played by Rebecca Olson
Midwife
Characters played by Shaun Parry
Attacker #3
Characters played by Annie Pasmann
Katherine Smith
Characters played by Dave Peterson
Bailiff
Characters played by Jyllian Petrie
Lucy Harris
Characters played by Vicky Piercey
Martin Harris Neighbor #1
Characters played by Alexander Platt
Christian Whitmer
Characters played by Jacob Richman
John Boynton
Characters played by Jordan Sawyer
William Smith
Characters played by Stevie Schaeffer
Catherine Whitmer
Characters played by Darin Scott
Luke Johnson
Characters played by Duane Stephens
Prosecutor
Characters played by Shawn Stevens
Judge Tiffany
Characters played by Elliotte Stewart
Alvin Smith (newborn)
Characters played by Lue Stirland
Baseball Boy
Characters played by Cora Stone
Harris Child #1
Characters played by Frederik Storm
Hooligan #3
Characters played by Frederik Storm
Hooligan #3
Characters played by Amanda Taylor
Lucy Harris Friend #2
Characters played by Brittany Thomas
Martin Harris Neighbor #2
Characters played by Samantha Rose Valletta
Elizabeth Cowdery
Characters played by Jack Wright
David Whitmer
Jr. (18 months)
Characters played by Colin Wylie
Sign Painter
Characters played by Zachary Zamsky
Treasure Man #2
Characters played by Jerome Brad Halgren
a Judge and a Juror