Characters played by Joey Lawrence
Luke MacLaren
Characters played by Leigh-Allyn Baker
Elizabeth MacLaren
Characters played by Anna Fricks
Anna MacLaren
Characters played by Bill Engvall
Santa
Characters played by Alexandra Boylan
Rebekah
Characters played by Jeff Schroeder
Paul MacLaren
Characters played by Ryan Boudreau
Colton Smith
Characters played by Bethany Peterson
Meredith
Characters played by Ivy Croteau
Rachel
Characters played by Chelsea Crockett
Ava
Characters played by Alex Boylan
Turner
Characters played by Sean T. Ward
Alex Smith
Characters played by Allie Shery
Hazel
Characters played by Kristina Byerley
High School Student
Characters played by Ryan Cannister
Extra
Characters played by Andrew Maiorano
Business Radio DJ
Characters played by Jacob Andres Padilla
College Boy
Characters played by Andrea Polnaszek
Pastor Paul's Wife
Characters played by Isabelle Polnaszek
Pastor Paul's Daughter
Characters played by Jael Polnaszek
Pastor Paul's Daughter
Characters played by Theresa Sterling
College Girl #1
Characters played by Tallena Wiggins
Lady in church
Characters played by Wesley Cannon
Frat boy