Characters played by Becki Newton
Caryn Goldfarb
Characters played by Zachary Knighton
Stosh Lewandoski
Characters played by Meera Rohit Kumbhani
Zara Sandhu
Characters played by Nate Torrence
Eric Lewandoski
Characters played by Catherine Petra Villalobos
Darla
Characters played by David Wain
Howard
Characters played by Susie Essman
Evelyn Goldfarb
Characters played by Shari Albert
Susan Quinlan
Characters played by Rajeev Pahuja
Toll Taker Guarav
Characters played by Katie Aselton
April
Characters played by Willie Garson
Carl
Characters played by Renée Taylor
Nana
Characters played by Matt Besser
Toll Taker Kent
Characters played by Daniel Zolghadri
Frank
Characters played by Jason Antoon
CooKoo Schmoolie
Characters played by Richard Erdman
Carl's Grandfather
Characters played by Josh Casaubon
Marty
Characters played by Kylie Sparks
Jesse
Characters played by Renée Marino
Regina
Characters played by Tim Kang
Adam
Characters played by Jennifer Marsala
Annette
Characters played by Ben Giroux
Tony Brooks
Characters played by Kelly Jenrette
Becky
Characters played by Xango Henry
Security Guard
Characters played by Ashley Rae Spillers
Kayla
Characters played by Duane R. Shepard Sr.
Toll Taker Jimmy
Characters played by Mackenzie Yeager
Waitress
Characters played by Amazon Beard
Bar Patron
Characters played by John Charles Meyer
David
Characters played by Tohoru Masamune
Kenneth
Characters played by Abhi Trivedi
Toll Taker Vijay
Characters played by Jessica Lu
Molly
Characters played by Catherine Carlen
Rachel
Characters played by Rebecca Drysdale
Toll Taker Miranda
Characters played by Holland MacFallister
Ted
Characters played by Carmine Caridi
Melvin
Characters played by Noel Arthur
Bruce
Characters played by Keith Reay
Eugene
Characters played by Eric Nigg
Toll Taker Mario
Characters played by Lee Weaver
Mortician
Characters played by Ervin Ross
Driver
Characters played by Jay Onrait
Jay Onrait
Characters played by Alek Cole
Oldest Kid
Characters played by Annie Abrams
Bride
Characters played by Dan O'Toole
Dan O'Toole
Characters played by Mark Provencher
Groom
Characters played by John Ross Clark
Minister
Characters played by Logan Paul
Logan Twins
Characters played by Tom Archdeacon
Eddie
Characters played by Toy Lei
Toll Taker Bev
Characters played by Amir Abdalla
Schmoolie
Characters played by Matt Austin
Jogging Man
Characters played by Kevin Mukherji
Toll Taker Singh
Characters played by Cristy Joy
Comedy Dancer
Characters played by Lee Anne Ford
Waitress
Characters played by Sean Decker
White Knight
Characters played by Kendal Murray
Kyle
Characters played by Ben Guenther
White Bishop