Characters played by Mary Kate Wiles
Artemis Schue-Horyn
Characters played by Steve Zaragoza
Paul Schue-Horyn
Characters played by Spencer Devlin Howard
America's Favorite Podcast Host
Characters played by Jacqueline Emerson
Rebecca
Characters played by Sean Astin
Lesly Stone
Characters played by Joanna Sotomura
Madison Reynolds
Characters played by Carlos Valdes
Dr. Henry Edwards
Characters played by Corey Dorris
Quinn Cassidy
Characters played by Dylan Saunders
Desmond Brewer
Characters played by Brian Rosenthal
Wallis Gale
Characters played by Joey Richter
Crispin Lynch
Characters played by Lauren Lopez
Agnes Florentine
Characters played by Sinead Persaud
Rita Waldeburg
Characters played by Clayton Snyder
Vern Marrow
Characters played by Tara Perry
Olivia Tompkins
Riley Kirkland
Characters played by Amrita Dhaliwal
Prism
Characters played by Jon Cozart
Donny Meadows
Characters played by Brendan Bradley
Odie Doty
Characters played by Ed Powell
Ed Puppetman
Characters played by Ashley Clements
Mary Jo Walker
Characters played by Gabe Greenspan
Ellis Walker
Characters played by Daniel Strauss
Barney Fletcher
Characters played by Gavyn Pickens
Helen Unger
Characters played by Nick Lang
Aubrey Dockweiler
Characters played by Paul Komoroski
Garmen Patrick Saget
Characters played by Sean Persaud
Rev. Jeremiah Stillwater
Characters played by Curt Mega
Cliff Irons
Characters played by Whitney Avalon
Rocky Irons
Characters played by Ryan Simpkins
Jewel Irons
Characters played by A.J. Holmes
Sybilus Silver II
Characters played by Titus Makin Jr.
Silas Torsen
Characters played by Sarah Grace Hart
The Mayor's Handler
Characters played by Diane Lopez-Richter
The Mayor
Characters played by Cassie Silva
Truman Hensley
Characters played by Darren Criss
Ryan Reynolds
Characters played by Rahul Thakkar
Akshay Sherma
Characters played by Corey Lubowich
Man at Crime Scene