Characters played by Beth Holloway-Twitty
Self
Host
Self - Host
Characters played by Ron Bradley
Self
Characters played by Iva Bradley
Self
Characters played by Craig Taylor Brown
Ron Bradley
Characters played by Ginny Dice
Iva Bradley
Characters played by Amanda Reed
Amy Bradley
Characters played by Noreen Gosch
Self - Johnny's Mother
Characters played by John Gosch Sr.
Self - Johnny's Father
Characters played by Brandon Bell
Alister Douglas
Characters played by Johnny Gosch
Self - Missing Person
Characters played by Jessica Lunsford
Self
Characters played by Natalee Holloway
Self - Victim
Characters played by Jennifer Walker
Kristin Smart's Mother
Characters played by Russ Ptacek
Reporter
Characters played by Courtney Lee Simpson
College Student
Characters played by Kevin Dillon
Cicago Police Dept.
Characters played by Susan Blake
Self - Joey's Mother
Characters played by Richard Petrone Jr.
Self - Missing Person
Characters played by Marc Allen
Self - Missing Person
Characters played by Derek Moorhead
Faculty Advisor
Characters played by Matthew Smart
Self - Kristin's Brother
Characters played by Chantal Savage
Radio Personality
Characters played by Michael McStay
Self - Joey's Brother
Characters played by Brad Swanson
Belton Police Dept.
Characters played by Brad Bradley
Self
Characters played by Danielle Imbo
Self - Missing Person
Characters played by Frank Santiago
Self - Retired Reporter
Characters played by Denise Smart
Self - Kristin's Mother
Characters played by Mary Steele
Judy
Characters played by Donna Ross
Jesse's mother
Characters played by Amy Lynn Bradley
Self - Missing Person
Characters played by Donald Ross
Jesse's father
Characters played by Andy Ross
Jesse's brother
Characters played by Dirk Tarpley
FBI
Characters played by Rhonda Beckford
Kara's mother
Characters played by Lindsey Smart
Self - Kristin's Sister
Characters played by Afton Sánchez
Kara's friend
Characters played by Jacob Johnson
Brad Bradley
Characters played by Alie Berrelez
Self - Missing Person
Characters played by Tracy Russell
Self - Summer's Sister
Characters played by Eugene Martin
Self - Missing Person
Characters played by Megan Heimer
Jesse's friend
Characters played by Troy Dugal
Self - San Diego Sheriff's Det.
Characters played by Jim Beckford
Kara's stepfather