Characters played by Jason Sudeikis
Andrew McCabe
Characters played by Rebecca Hall
Hannah
Characters played by Joe Manganiello
Curtis
Characters played by Dianna Agron
Finley
Characters played by Blythe Danner
Linda
Characters played by Griffin Dunne
Upton
Characters played by Richard Masur
Bruce
Characters played by Maggie Castle
Shannon
Characters played by Kimberly Howe
Hippie
Characters played by Alex Quijano
Ben
Characters played by Mary-Bonner Baker
Heidi
Characters played by Bates Wilder
Metal Head
Characters played by Matthew Delamater
Seth
Characters played by Pepper Binkley
Girl Fan
Characters played by Gabe Gibbs
Ethan Woodcock
Characters played by Meredith Prunty
Student
Characters played by Tierre Diaz
Student
Characters played by Haley Pine
Girl getting ice cream
Characters played by Mark Burzenski
College Student
Characters played by Melanie Ehrlich
Bookstore Employee
Characters played by Zachariah Supka
Bookstore Kid
Characters played by Damien Jurado
Hunter
Characters played by Stanis Krista Ames
Student
Characters played by Graham King
Guitar Player
Characters played by Emily Kokidko
Teen Party Goer
Characters played by Hashim Lafond
Hofstra Student
Characters played by Mary Klug
Esther
Characters played by Claire Haley
Megan
Characters played by Carl 'CJ' Tempesta
Teen Party Goer
Characters played by Steven Dougherty
Local Scruffy
Cowboy
Characters played by George J. Vezina
Pedestrian
Characters played by Melissa Jesser
Melissa
Characters played by Lindsay Boffoli
Ice Cream Lady
Characters played by Eddie Resendes
Hofstra Student
Characters played by Eva Senerchia
Storytime Kid
Characters played by Frank Omar
Reggie
Characters played by John Hickson
Al
Characters played by Josh Gunderson
Hipster
Characters played by Lewis Robinson
Scruffy Local
Characters played by Caroline Cronin
Student
Characters played by David Boston
Town Person
Characters played by Stacey Deddo
Party Goer
Characters played by Lily Gavin
Storytime Kid
Characters played by Rosemary Howard
Party Goer
Characters played by Gary Roscoe
Partygoer