Characters played by Margaret O'Brien
Mrs. Foxworth
Characters played by Ronn Moss
Gatekeeper
Characters played by Brandon Tyler Russell
Jerry
Characters played by Donna Spangler
Angelina
Characters played by Megan Duffy
Nina
Characters played by Simona Fusco
Yvonne
Characters played by Vincent De Paul
James Bennett Foxworth
Characters played by Andrea Boccaletti
Anthony
Characters played by Timothy Davis
Martin Thomas
Characters played by Nancy Daly
Aunt Maggie
Characters played by Zac Weinstein
Otto
Characters played by Stanley B. Herman
Herb
Characters played by Sammy The Dwarf
Elf
Characters played by Laura Grady
Molly Bennett Foxworth
Characters played by Ravin Spangler
Ravin Bennett Foxworth
Characters played by Kira Reed Lorsch
Mrs. Hawkins
Characters played by Daisy Lang
Natasha Hipsteiner
Characters played by Igor Korosec
Hector
Characters played by Yuriy Zubarev
Joseph
Characters played by Ed Taylor
Santa Claus
Characters played by Amber Bernstein
Lia
Characters played by Mara Rydell
Lucille
Characters played by Thomas Beaumont
Deacon Scott
Characters played by Jordon Chu
Lois
Characters played by Elizabeth Webster
Beth Anne
Characters played by Aaron O'Connell
Nathan Winslow
Characters played by Natalie Pack
Laura Winslow
Characters played by Joel Rush
Mike Davenport
Characters played by Jesse Kove
Mr. Turner
Characters played by Randal Malone
Bakery Santa
Characters played by Laurie Kagan
Apples Customer
Characters played by Steven Suerder
Driver
Characters played by Brad Oberholtzer
Voice of God