Characters played by Odette Annable
Casey Beldon
Characters played by Gary Oldman
Rabbi Sendak
Characters played by Cam Gigandet
Mark
Characters played by Meagan Good
Romy
Characters played by Idris Elba
Arthur Wyndham
Characters played by Jane Alexander
Sofi Kozma
Characters played by Atticus Shaffer
Matty Newton
Characters played by James Remar
Gordon Beldon
Characters played by Carla Gugino
Janet Beldon
Characters played by C.S. Lee
Dr. Lester Caldwell
Characters played by Rhys Coiro
Mr. Shields
Characters played by Michael Sassone
Eli Walker
Characters played by Ethan Cutkosky
Barto
Characters played by Craig J. Harris
Rick Hesse
Characters played by Rachel Brosnahan
Lisa
Characters played by Kymberly Mellen
Gail Newton
Characters played by Brian Boland
Roger Newton
Characters played by Mindy Bell
Librarian
Characters played by Roslyn Alexander
Evelyn
Characters played by Maury Cooper
Grandfather
Characters played by Mandy Schneider
Housewife
Characters played by Guy Van Swearingen
Library Guard
Characters played by Ericka Ratcliff
Charge Nurse
Characters played by Savannah Walker
Seven Year Old Casey
Characters played by Domenica Fisher
Gordon's Secretary
Characters played by Marssie Mencotti
Mrs. Byrne
Characters played by Sarah Wellington
Ob
Gyn Doctor
Characters played by Alexis Wade
Nine Year Old Sofi
Characters played by Tom Lowell
Library Patron
Characters played by Kenya Drew
Student
Characters played by Scott Lindvall
Detective
Characters played by Braden Moran
Joseph Mengele
Characters played by Aiden David
Newton Baby
Characters played by Connor David
Newton Baby
Characters played by Lili Haydn
Singer
Characters played by John Bryant
Musician
Characters played by Richard Mosely
Musician
Characters played by Ronnie Sellers
Musician
Characters played by Tommy Bartlett
Crime Scene Investigator
Characters played by Joey Bicicchi
College Classmate
Characters played by Roarke Boes
Basketball Player
Characters played by Suzy Brack
Eye Clinic Receptionist
Characters played by Joe Caballero
Chicago Cop
Characters played by Circus-Szalewski
Psychotic Vagrant
Characters played by Evyenia Constantine
Club Dancer
Characters played by Alan Deutsch
Club Dancer
Characters played by Joe DeVito
Neighbor
Characters played by Shannon Edwards
Synagogue Employee
Characters played by Robert Erck
Forensic Assistant
Characters played by Marilyn Jacobs
Dancer
Characters played by Arianna Lexus
College Student
Characters played by Jamie Louachai
Neighbor
Characters played by J.R. Martino
Extra
Characters played by Larry Nazimek
Auschwitz Doctor
Characters played by James Pusztay
AAA Group Member
Characters played by T'Neil Wise
Club Dancer
Characters played by Niko El Santo Zavero
Synagogue Employee