Characters played by Sherry Stringfield
Laura Mayfield-Bennett
Characters played by Sarah Maine
Jessica
Characters played by Willie Stratford
Theodore
Characters played by Danielle Panabaker
Katie Lapp
Characters played by Jason Loughlin
Benjamin Lapp
Characters played by Sandra Elise Williams
Rebecca Lapp
Characters played by Bill Oberst Jr.
Samuel Lapp
Characters played by Wyatt Lanier
Jacob Beiler
Characters played by Burgess Jenkins
Bishop John Beiler
Characters played by Dalton Parrish
Hickory John Beiler
Characters played by David Topp
Daniel Fisher
Characters played by Richard Fullerton
Ephram Yoder
Characters played by Nancy Saunders
Ella Mae Zook
Characters played by Rachel St. Gelais
Benjamin's Daughter
Characters played by Jana Allen
Amanda
Characters played by Sarah E. Chambers
Mary Stoltzfus
Characters played by Tim Holt
Dylan Bennett
Characters played by Michele Lee
Store Clerk
Characters played by Jimmy Hager
Preacher Yoder
Characters played by David Forrester
Amish Elder
Characters played by Scott Helm
Amish Man
Characters played by Robert C. Treveiler
Surgeon
Characters played by Stephen West-Rogers
Trauma Nurse
Characters played by Lee Freeman
Nurse Rosie
Characters played by Alexa Yeames
Young Laura
Characters played by Jacob Allen
Young Amish Bachelor
Characters played by Tara-Nicole Azarian
Amish Teenager
Characters played by Kirk Bass
Young Samuel
Characters played by Leanne Bernard
Bus Patron
Characters played by Randy Bernard
Bus Patron
Characters played by Hailey Best
Self
Nurse
Characters played by Elijah Chester
Amish Guy
Characters played by Darren W. Conrad
Amish Man
Characters played by Lee Ryan Coston
Amish Woman in Shop
Characters played by Christina Cupo
Bus Patron
Characters played by Beth Gosnell
Amish woman
Characters played by Beth Hawkes
Wedding Guest
Characters played by Tessa Taylor Herrick
Amish Woman in Cab
Characters played by Nick Karner
Amish Man at General Store
Characters played by Dan A.R. Kelly
Amish Man
Characters played by Jerry Keys
Amish Elder
Characters played by Janine Lorraine
Amish Woman
Characters played by Jason Mac
Noah Beiler
Characters played by Chris Manitius
Young Boy
Characters played by Shasta Mejia
Hotel Guest
Characters played by Melissa Milch
Young Amish Woman
Characters played by Addy Miller
Amish Girl
Characters played by David R. Moore
Young Amish Man
Characters played by Gary Ray Moore
Amish Man
Characters played by Lindsey Moser
Nurse
Characters played by Tina Murphy
Young Rebecca
Characters played by David Dickson Reynolds
Amish Elder
Characters played by Karen Wheeling Reynolds
Amish Woman
Characters played by Chris Sprister
Amish Man
Characters played by Brandi Alyssa Young
Amish Woman