Characters played by Paul McCloskey
Wayne Montgomery
Characters played by Barbara Lessin
Andrea Montgomery
Characters played by Brinke Stevens
Julie Quinn
Characters played by Michael J. Panichelli Jr.
Detective John Haynes
Characters played by Joey Garrison
Jared
Characters played by Devin Kates
Seth
Characters played by David M. Sitbon
Grey Mortimer
Characters played by Mark Cray
John Craven
Characters played by Colleen Hawthorne
Kathy Cole
Characters played by Anne Reiss
Kaylah
Characters played by Kati Jordan
Holly
Characters played by Tony Kates
Robert
Characters played by Art Lyle
John 'Jack' Hambrick
Characters played by Meredith Fagioli
Victim
Characters played by Geoff Lutz
Max Stevens
Characters played by Anthony Mecca
Eligio Bonelli
Characters played by Amanda Higgins
Victim
Characters played by Melissa Torrence
M.J.
Characters played by Lyle Xayvier
Victim
Characters played by Kaylah Fitzgerald
Debra Castille-Hall
Characters played by Beth Kates
Victim
Characters played by Judy Buckley
Ellie
Characters played by Nina Kates
Victim
Characters played by Kevin Ashley
Chester Donnell
Characters played by Fallon Marie Mitchell
Victim
Characters played by Tracy Johnson
Renee
Characters played by Emily Spiegel
Monica Montgomery
Characters played by Anthony Spadaccini
Narrator
Characters played by Jeff Watson
Joe Mitchell
Characters played by Steve Brown
Pastor Vernon Cole
Characters played by Jay Cusack
TV Interviewer
Characters played by Sunayana Chowdhury
Victim
Characters played by Joe O'Donnell
Victim
Characters played by Robert Underwood
Victim
Characters played by John Wallo
Victim
Characters played by Stephanie Wallo
Victim
Characters played by Timothy Wilson
Victim