Characters played by Gregory Harrison
Joseph
Characters played by Helen Hunt
Mary
Characters played by Vincent Price
King Herod
Characters played by David Ackroyd
Angel of the Lord
Characters played by Roscoe Lee Browne
Wise Man
Characters played by Darleen Carr
Margo
Characters played by Richard Erdman
(as Dick Erdman)
Characters played by Scott Grimes
Yasha
Characters played by Richard Libertini
Characters played by Terence McGovern
Derek
Characters played by Alan Oppenheimer
Wise Man #2
Melon Merchant
Characters played by Rob Paulsen
Moki
Characters played by Michael Rye
Narrator
Characters played by Jeffrey Tambor
Eli
Characters played by Frank Welker
Roman Soldier