Characters played by John Johnson
Saint Nick
Characters played by Bubba Baltz
House Guest #2
Characters played by Terri Martin Baltz
Grace
Characters played by Tobias Doesken
Mike McMullen
Characters played by Monique Dupree
Miss Cleo
Characters played by Matthew Ewald
Hayden
Characters played by Lisa Gale
Christmas Judge #3
Characters played by Royce Hobson
Stevie McMullen
Characters played by Mariah Johnson
Ariel Aris
Characters played by Jarod Kearney
Caleb
Characters played by Elissa Lauer
Jen
Characters played by Kristen Lilla
Christmas Judge #1
Characters played by Karrie A. Lyons-Munkittrick
Christmas Judge #2
Characters played by Emily Malloch
Annie
Characters played by Jonny Rum Runner Moore
House Guest #1
Characters played by Robin Ramsay
Trixie
Characters played by Asbel Reyes
Warren
Characters played by Candi Zych
Christmas Judge #4