Characters played by Michael Jai White
Milo
Characters played by Angelique Rivera
Olivia Shaw
Characters played by Cameron Jebo
Noah Harris
Characters played by Dmitrious Bistrevsky
The Crooked Man
Characters played by Dina Meyer
Margaret
Characters played by Amber Benson
Grace Hutchinson
Characters played by Marco Rodríguez
Matthew Shaw
Characters played by Reilly Brooke Stith
Charlotte
Characters played by Brianne Tju
Violet
Characters played by Alexis Wilkins
Alice
Characters played by Dia Frampton
Mia Johanssen
Characters played by Daniel Booko
Steven
Characters played by John Colton
Sheriff Palmer
Characters played by Isabella Day
Young Olivia
Characters played by Lexi Underwood
Young Charlotte