Characters played by Rick Edwards
Self - Host
Characters played by Amanda Berry
Self
Characters played by Sylvia Browne
Self - Psychic
Characters played by Ariel Castro
Self
Characters played by Onil Castro
Self
Characters played by Pedro Castro
Self
Characters played by Gina DeJesus
Self
Characters played by Tito DeJesus
Self - Band Member
Characters played by Kathleen DeMetz
Self - Ariel Castro's Defense Attorney
Characters played by Angie Gregg
Self - Ariel Castro's Daughter
Characters played by Deborah Knight
Self - Michelle's Grandmother
Characters played by Michelle Knight
Self
Characters played by Lynna Lai
Self - Reporter
Characters played by Gerald Malone
Self - Doctor
Characters played by Aurora Marti
Self - Neighbor
Characters played by Daniel Marti
Self - Neighbor
Characters played by Javier Marti
Self - Neighbor
Characters played by Betsy Martinez
Self - Nurse
Characters played by Timothy McGinty
Self - Prosecutor
Characters played by Tom Meyer
Self - Investigative Reporter
Characters played by Louwana Miller
Self - Amanda Berry's Mother
Characters played by Maria Montes
Self - Ariel Castro's Cousin
Characters played by Paul Orlousky
Self - News Anchor
Characters played by Jen Picciano
Self - Reporter
Characters played by Charles Ramsey
Self - Neighbor
Characters played by Ricky Sanchez
Self - Musician
Characters played by Beth Serrano
Self - Amanda Berry's Sister
Characters played by Jim Simone
Self - Retired Cleveland Police Officer
Characters played by Luis Sotl
Self - Gina's Uncle
Characters played by Craig Weintraub
Self - Defense Attorney
Characters played by Montel Williams
Self