Characters played by Jamie Luner
Rachel Carter
Characters played by Johnny Messner
Michael Pryor
Characters played by Kassandra Clementi
Emma
Characters played by William McNamara
Brad
Characters played by Maria Breese
Janis
Characters played by Marcie Barkin
Donna
Characters played by Edward Beckford
Church Deacon
Characters played by Mel Fair
Tony Bruno
Characters played by Jenine Galante
Gaga
Characters played by Chelsey Goldsmith
Tamala
Characters played by Jack Griffo
Todd
Characters played by Betsy Hume
Waitress
Characters played by William Katt
Dr. Dennis Carter
Characters played by Aaron Lee
Dr. Sandler
Characters played by Bill Lewis
Santa Claus
Characters played by Laurie Love
Tina
Characters played by Patrick McLain
Bartender
Characters played by Brandon Middleton
Pastor Davis
Characters played by Madeline Grace Popovich
Sophia Pryor
Characters played by Andrea Ridgeway
Ellen
Characters played by Hannah Schooping-Gutierrez
Mary
Characters played by Tyler Skiba
Joseph