Characters played by Chad Michael Murray
Ted Bundy
Characters played by Holland Roden
Kathleen McChesney
Characters played by Jake Hays
Robert Ressler
Characters played by Lin Shaye
Mrs. Bundy
Characters played by Greer Grammer
Cheryl Thomas
Characters played by Olivia DeLaurentis
Carol DaRonch
Characters played by Julianne Collins
Melissa Smith
Characters played by Gianna Adams
Jill Johnson
Characters played by Dashiell Connery
Bobby Kelske
Characters played by Anthony De Longis
Herb Swindley
Characters played by Sky Liam Patterson
Shane Swindley
Characters played by Gabrielle Haugh
Laura Aime
Characters played by Asante Jones
Dr. Richmore
Characters played by Diane Franklin
Mrs. Healy
Characters played by Jo Beth Locklear
Heather
Characters played by Alice Prime
Dottie
Characters played by Leslie Stratton
Margaret
Characters played by Marietta Melrose
Karen
Characters played by Alexandra Scott
Lisa
Characters played by McKenna Alvizo
Kathy
Characters played by Fivel Stewart
Valerie
Characters played by David Hill
Sheriff
Characters played by Rosemberg Salgado
Deputy
Characters played by Christian Lopez
Jogger
Characters played by Jason Caceres
Jogger
Characters played by Duke Jones
Officer
Characters played by Jeremie Fiore
Paramedic
Characters played by Steven P. Nemphos
Paramedic
Characters played by Dan Olson
Academy Cadet
Characters played by Jeff Morgan
Academy Cadet
Characters played by Robert Hernandez
Academy Cadet
Characters played by Troy Dillinger
Academy Cadet
Characters played by Luke Matheis
Academy Cadet
Characters played by Jeffrey Newell
Task Force Detective
Characters played by Scott Lea
Task Force Detective
Characters played by William "Will" Daubert
Task Force Detective
Characters played by Jose Rosete
Utah Detective
Characters played by Rebecca Louise
Female Figure
Characters played by Chelsea Brea
Female Figure
Characters played by Emily Coupe
Female Figure
Characters played by William Costello
Frat Brother
Characters played by Miguel Marvin
Frat Brother
Characters played by Justin Meier
Frat Brother
Characters played by Byron Garcia
Trick-or-Treater
Characters played by AprilAnn Dais
Trick-or-Treater
Characters played by Gregory Gonzalez
Hospital Janitor
Characters played by Alfred Gabidullin
County Jail Guard
Characters played by Robert Hepburn
Coroner
Characters played by Vivian Tse
Waitress
Characters played by Katie Tripp
Popcorn Girl
Characters played by Zoë Kasch
Ann Marie Burr
Characters played by Scarlet Carles
Kimberly Leach
Characters played by Aly Rae Santos-Tanner
Kerri