Characters played by Erin Lehn
Christine Tucker
Characters played by Jarrett Brown
Carl Radowski
Characters played by Penny Shaw
Dia Douglas
Characters played by Annie Rimmer-Weeks
Mickey Phelps
Characters played by Jonathon Zilka
Detective Dave Johnson
Det. Dave Johnson
Characters played by Sid Louie
Jack Kawai
Characters played by Adam Dunlap
Blaine Hammerschmidt
Characters played by David Loftus
Ezekiel Radowski
Man in Dark Suit
Mysterious Figure on Far Sidewalk
Person Dragging Body
Trick-or-treaters' Dad
Whistling passerby
Characters played by Nadir Muhammad
Detective Jericho Francis
Det. Jericho Francis
Characters played by Dennis Kelly
Bryan Bates
Bates
Bryan
Characters played by Jayne Stevens
Chelsea Garvin
Characters played by Sandra Doolittle
Pearline Radowski
Characters played by Sasha Dadvar
Detective Adam Cloud
Characters played by Bryce Earhart
Doogie
Characters played by Nicole Seeley
Amanda Addelson
Characters played by Nico Floresca
Chloe Dela Cruz
Olivia
the devil trick-or-treater
Trick-or-treater #1
Characters played by Shelly Burbidge
Rebecca 'Angel' Michaels
Characters played by Jeff Bundy
Ben Harding
Body hanging in barn
Characters played by Jared Souza
Philip French
Characters played by Karen Bell
Mrs. Dave Johnson
Characters played by JoAnna Ziemba
Patron
Characters played by Kelli Williams
Dolled-up body in attic