Characters played by Sarah Michelle Gellar
Amanda Shelton
Characters played by Sean Patrick Flanery
Tom Bartlett
Characters played by Patricia Clarkson
Lois McNally
Characters played by Dylan Baker
Jonathan Bendel
Characters played by Lawrence Gilliard Jr.
Nolan Traynor
Characters played by Christopher Durang
Gene O'Reilly
Characters played by Betty Buckley
Aunt Stella
Characters played by Olek Krupa
Valderon
Characters played by Amanda Peet
Chris
Characters played by Alex Draper
Francois
Characters played by Drew Nieporent
Gil Shapiro
Characters played by Anthony Ruivivar
Ramos
Characters played by Andrew McFarlane
The Poet
Characters played by Steven Skybell
Mr. Mueller
Characters played by Phyllis Somerville
Ruth