Characters played by Brian d'Arcy James
Shrek
Characters played by Sutton Foster
Fiona
Characters played by Christopher Sieber
Lord Farquaad
Characters played by John Tartaglia
Pinocchio
Magic Mirror
Dragon Puppeteer
Characters played by Daniel Breaker
Donkey
Characters played by Marissa O'Donnell
Teen Fiona
Characters played by Leah Greenhaus
Young Fiona
Characters played by Haven Paschall
Sugar Plum Fairy
Gingy
Dragonette
Characters played by Jennifer Cody
Duloc Doll
Characters played by Bobby Daye
Sticks
Bishop
Characters played by Ryan Duncan
Bricks
Skeleton
Characters played by Sarah Jane Everman
Ugly Duckling
Blind Mouse
Characters played by Aymee Garcia
Mama Bear
Dragonette
Characters played by Maya Goldman
Young Shrek
Dwarf
Characters played by Justin Greer
Swing
Duloc Doll
Characters played by Colleen Hawkes
Fairy Godmother
Bluebird
Characters played by Lisa Ho
Baby Bear
Blind Mouse
Characters played by Chris Hoch
Big Bad Wolf
Captain of the Guards
Characters played by Danette Holden
Duloc Doll
Characters played by Marty Lawson
Guard
Characters played by Carolyn Ockert-Haythe
Swing
Duloc Doll
Characters played by Cameron Adams
Ensemble
Characters played by Denny Paschall
Peter Pan
Skeleton
Characters played by Greg Reuter
Duloc Doll
Characters played by Noah Rivera
White Rabbit
Skeleton
Characters played by Heather Jane Rolff
Swing
Duloc Doll
Characters played by Jennifer Simard
Wicked Witch
Characters played by Rachel Stern
Mama Ogre
Tweedle Dum
Dragonette
Characters played by Dennis Stowe
Papa Bear
Thelonious
Skeleton
Characters played by Jacob Ming-Trent
Papa Ogre
Straw
Characters played by Tessa Albertson
Teen Fiona (segment "I'm a Believer")
Characters played by David F.M. Vaughn
Mad Hatter
Skeleton
Pied Piper
Characters played by Rozi Baker
Young Fiona (segments "Big Bright Beautiful World" and "I'm a Believer")
Characters played by Kirsten Wyatt
Shoemaker's Elf
Blind Mouse
Characters played by James Germano
Shrek
Characters played by Charles Duncan McGowan
Guard
Swing
Characters played by Bella Szpala
Guard #1