Characters played by Anthony D. Call
Narrator
Characters played by Jeff Belanger
Self - Paranormal Investigator
Host of New England Legends
Self - Author
Self - Author
Communicating with the Dead
Characters played by Jason Hawes
Self - Paranormal Investigator
Self - Ghost Nation
Characters played by Dave Schrader
Self
Self - Holzer Files
Self - Paranormal Investigator
Characters played by Lisa Morton
Self - Author
'Trick or Treat: A History of Halloween'
Self - Author
Ghosts: A Haunted History
Characters played by Laurene Gomez
Self - Assisted Warren Investigations
Self - Licensed Psychotherapist & Forensic Counselor
Characters played by Cindy Kaza
Self - Holzer Files
Self - Host
Psychic Medium
Characters played by Laura DiDio
Self - Reporter
Characters played by Rikki Rockett
Self - Drummer
Poison & Legend Tripper
Self - Paranormal Investigator
Characters played by Melissa Tittl
Self
Self - Investigative Journalist
Characters played by Steven 'Prozak' Shippy
Self - Host
Paranormal Investigator and Documentary Filmmaker
Characters played by Steve Gonsalves
Self - Ghost Nation
Characters played by Vincent Lampert
Self - Exorcist Priest
Archdiocese of Indianapolis
Characters played by Michael Salerno
Self - Catholic Demonologist
Characters played by Tim Yancey
Self - Paranormal Investigator
Characters played by Lauren Parker
Self - Paranormal Investigator
Characters played by Amy Bruni
Self - Kindred Spirits
Characters played by Marc D'Antonio
Self - UFO Investigator
Characters played by Michelle Fenski
Self - Paranormal Investigator
Characters played by Bryce Johnson
Self - Expedition Bigfoot
Characters played by Judy Spera
Self - Ed & Lorraine's Daughter
Characters played by Dave Bignell
Self - Plainfield Local
Characters played by Marty Minnella
Self - Criminal Defense Attorney
Characters played by Marcus Harvey
Self - Ghost Brothers
Characters played by Bill Hall
Self - Author
'The World's Most Haunted House'
Characters played by Joshua P. Warren
Self - Paranormal Expert
Characters played by John Waide
Self - Archivist Emeritus
St. Louis University
Characters played by Tom Dyar
Self - Local Resident
Characters played by Lesley Bannatyne
Self - Halloween Author
Characters played by Arne Cheyenne Johnson
Self - Debbie's Boyfriend
Characters played by Marvin Scott
Self - Sr News Correspondent - WPIX
Characters played by Lori McCloud
Self - Plainfield Historian
Characters played by Terry Cooper
Self - Research Psychoanalyst and Retired Professor
Characters played by Tok Thompson
Self - Author
'Posthuman Folklore'
Characters played by Paul Eno
Self - Paranormal Investigator
Characters played by Eric Walter
Self - Director - My Amityville Horror
Characters played by Andy Thundercloud
Self - Ho-Chunk Tribe Elder
Characters played by Jason Emerson
Self - Historian
Characters played by Steven LaChance
Author
'Confrontation with Evil'
Self - Investigator
Characters played by Karen Hollis
Self - Psychic Medium
Characters played by Michelle Gullion
Self - Director of Research
National First Ladies Library
Characters played by Adam Berry
Self - Kindred Spirits
Characters played by Tony Spera
Self - Son-in-Law & Host
'Seekers of the Supernatural'
Characters played by Timothy Perez-Ross
Ed Gein
Characters played by John Buescher
Self - Author
The President's Medium
Characters played by John Lucas
Self - Det. Sgt.
Brookfield P.D.
Ret.
Characters played by Chip Coffey
Self - Kindred Spirits
Characters played by Kera O'Bryon
Augusta Gein
Characters played by Robert Broski
Abraham Lincoln
Characters played by Joe Vetter
Self - Friend of George Lutz
Characters played by Matthew Wilkinson
Self - Mental Health Counselor
Characters played by Joe Lamparelli
Self - Patrolman
Brookfield P.D.
Ret.
Characters played by Alex Stavrevski
Young Ed Gein
Characters played by Anna Brungardt
Mary Todd Lincoln
Characters played by Eileen Dreyer
Self - Great-Niece of Father William Bowdern
Characters played by Anna Brungart
Mary Todd Lincoln
Characters played by Margaret Ellis
Norman's Wife
Self - Brookfield Resident
Characters played by Dave Tango
Self - Ghost Nation
Characters played by Ben Eno
Self - Paranormal Investigator
Characters played by Danny Hansen
Franklin Pierce
Characters played by Norman T. Ellis
Self - Capt.
Brookfield Vol. F.D.
Ret.
Characters played by Francoise Dermine
Self - Exorcist Priest
Archdiocese of Ancona-Osimo
Italy
Characters played by Ronny Leblanc
Self - Expedition Bigfoot
Characters played by Talia Martin
Jane Pierce
Characters played by Greg Holewinski
Self - Ret. Alexian Brother
Characters played by John B. Harris
Self - Reporter
Hartford Courant
Characters played by Chelsea Laden
Self - Destination Fear
Characters played by Kenneth Jones
Diary Voice
Characters played by Dieter H. Kiesel Jr.
Demon
Characters played by Tanner Wiseman
Self - Destination Fear
Characters played by Sandor Stern
Self - Screenwriter
The Amityville Horror
Characters played by Caden Conrique
Roland Doe
Characters played by Alex Schroeder
Self - Destination Fear
Characters played by Jerry Solfvin
Self - Parapsychologist
Characters played by David Conrique
Roland's Dad
Characters played by Sarah Heller
Roland's Mom
Characters played by Shane Pittman
Self - Holzer Files
Characters played by Will Roberts
Father Bowdern
Characters played by Dakota Laden
Self - Destination Fear
Characters played by David Hill
Father Bishop
Characters played by Carmen Snedeker-McHone
Self - Haunting Survivor
Characters played by Dan Olsen
Father Hughes
Characters played by Jimmy Petonito
Self - Paranormal Investigator
Characters played by Steven P. Nemphos
Father Holewinski
Characters played by Troy Dillinger
Reverend Schulze
Characters played by Dalen Spratt
Self - Ghost Brothers
Characters played by Kendall Chappell
Mary Doe
Characters played by Juwan Mass
Self - Ghost Brothers
Characters played by Lynda Gatlin
Aunt Tillie
Characters played by Russell Acord
Self - Expedition Bigfoot
Characters played by Lindsey Mallard
Roland's Aunt
Characters played by Mireya Mayor
Self - Expedition Bigfoot
Characters played by Matt Newman
[no data]
Characters played by Ben Hansen
Self - Extraterrestrial Investigator
Characters played by Ego Mikitas
Charles Colchester
Characters played by Elizabeth Becka
Abby Borden
Characters played by Tony DeMil
Anvelo
Characters played by Chris Fleming
Self
Characters played by Joseph Lopez
Priest
Characters played by Riley Madison Fuller
Mary Borden
Characters played by Sam Baltrusis
Self
Characters played by Brianna Quinn Lewis
Bridget Sullivan
Characters played by Ross Turner
Noah Brooks
Characters played by Eric VanDruff
Staffer
Characters played by Emily Paige Hogan
Sarah Maria Cornell
Characters played by Penelope Martone
Eliza Borden Jr.
Characters played by Robert Mitchel Owenby
Thomas Cornell
Characters played by Erik Scilley
John Wilkes Booth
Characters played by Stephanie Wyatt
Lizzie Borden
Characters played by Jason Flowers
Union Soldier
Characters played by Johnny Robish
Staffer
Characters played by Brayden Scott
Willie Lincoln
Characters played by Indiana Arnold
Bennie Pierce
Characters played by Kevin Edison
John Morse
Characters played by Troy Taylor
Self
Characters played by Filipe Abreu
Staffer
Characters played by Ariana Livingston
Eliza Borden
Characters played by Luann Joly
Self
Characters played by Tracy Lynn Jenson
Lizbeth Borden
Characters played by Adrian Snuffer
Margaretta Fox
Characters played by Brian Feys
Andrew Borden
Characters played by Luann Joy
Self
Characters played by Katharine Means
Leah Fox
Characters played by Devin Sanclemente
Staffer
Characters played by Michael Stempij
Reverend Avery
Characters played by Whitley Strieber
Self
Characters played by Alexandra Faye Sadeghian
Anne Strieber
Characters played by Theresa Croft
Christina Powell
Characters played by Timothy Greenfield-Sanders
Self
Characters played by Brooke Harrsch
Debbie Kauble
Characters played by Zach Shucklin
Young Whitley Strieber
Characters played by Tamas Bulla
Whitley's Son
Characters played by Raven Dana
Self
Characters played by Jeffrey J. Kripal
Self
Characters played by Mike Vertero
Jaques
Characters played by Rachel Cahoon
Visitor 2
Characters played by Suzanne K. Milton
Ghost
Visitor 3
Characters played by Elaina Gemmati
Annie Gottlieb
Characters played by Bartek Szymanski
Alan Glatzel
Characters played by Robbie Dema
Detective Lucas
Characters played by Sawyer Williams
Denny Layton
Characters played by Rachel Konstantin
Lorraine Warren
Characters played by Carlos Morrow
Arne Johnson
Characters played by Arielle Mandelberg
Debbie Glatzel
Characters played by Matthew Thompson
Male Skin-Walker
Characters played by Anthony Altieri
Joe Lamparelli
Characters played by Jay Gates
Sheriff Art Schley
Characters played by Chris Becker
Ed Warren
Characters played by Devon Juaire
Father Halloran
Characters played by Marty Whittle
Judy Glatzel