Characters played by Jim Brodhagen
Billy (Segment "A Christmas Horror Story")
Characters played by Danielle Brookshire
Danielle (segment "Shortly After Nightfall")
Characters played by Kevin A Casey
Dennie (segment "Shortly After Nightfall" "I Dream of Djinni")
Characters played by Jenny Chambers
Cora (segment "Deadbolt")
Characters played by Chianna
Bryce (Segment "Whispering Board")
Characters played by Dailen Cowden
Peter (segment "A Bad Heart" "A Christmas Horror Story")
Characters played by Steve Eaton
Justin (segment "Convention Girl" "Out of the Lamp")
Characters played by Julia Farrell
Tiffany (Segment "Whispering Board")
Characters played by Megan Garcia
Sabiah (Segment "I Dream of Djinni" "Out of the Lamp")
Characters played by Will Griffey
Greg (Segment "Last Breath")
Characters played by Jesse Hapke
Robert (Segment "I Dream of Djinni")
Characters played by Ali Hodson
Convention Girl (segment "Convention Girl")
Characters played by Rose Johnson
Rose (segment "Shortly After Nightfall")
Characters played by Joanna Kingsbury
Woman in White (segment "Shortly After Nightfall")
Characters played by Cody McDowell
Kyle (Segment "A Christmas Horror Story")
Characters played by Taylor Melone
Young Girl (Segment "I Dream of Djinni")
Characters played by Justin Milani
Josh (segment "Shortly After Nightfall")
Characters played by Eric Moyer
Man (segment "Birthday Dinner")
Characters played by Christina Olson
Jane (segment "A Bad Heart")
Characters played by Ted Perez
Jerry (Segment "A Christmas Horror Story")
Characters played by Mark Popejoy
Ray Dean Foster (segment "A Bad Heart")
Characters played by T.J. Roe
David (segment "Convention Girl")
Characters played by Genevieve Schmidt
Trick or Treat ghost (segment "Deadbolt")
Characters played by Tina Schmidt
Mother (segment "Deadbolt")
Characters played by Michelle Schrage
Woman (segment "Birthday Dinner")
Characters played by Dale Schumacher Jr.
Santa (Segment "A Christmas Horror Story")
Characters played by Kerrie Waybright Smith
Lauren (Segment "A Christmas Horror Story")
Characters played by Jazmyne Van Houten
Beth (Segment "Last Breath" "Whispering Board" "A Christmas Horror Story")