Characters played by Jennie Garth
Rebecca Chandler
Characters played by Steven Eckholdt
John Martin Carter
Characters played by Charles Robinson
Russell
Characters played by Joel McKinnon Miller
Harley
Characters played by Victor Raider-Wexler
Bob
Characters played by Josh Randall
Ryan
Characters played by Kathryn Joosten
Winifred
Characters played by Sam Anderson
Mr. Gibson
Characters played by Marnette Patterson
Callie
Characters played by Cody Fleetwood
Scotty
Characters played by Barbara Billingsley
Miss Ruthie
Characters played by Marilyn O'Connor
Betty
Characters played by Fiona Hale
Beatrice
Characters played by Nick Pietropaolo
The maitre'd
Characters played by John A. Keim
Santa Claus
Characters played by Rory Knox Johnston
Nathan
Characters played by Christin Taylor-Antonio
Restaurants diner
Characters played by Jessica Anne Bogart
Christmas Guest