Characters played by Jason Dohring
Elliot Knight
Characters played by Minka Kelly
Eden Mercer
Characters played by Masi Oka
Sonny Bosco
Characters played by Michael Hogan
Principal Faden
Characters played by Clarke Peters
The Narrator
Characters played by Nick Kocher
Calvin Knight
Characters played by Brian McElhaney
Gary Noble
Characters played by Michael Kagan
Mr. Mercer
Characters played by Matt Beckham
Vick
Characters played by Richard Folmer
Finley
Characters played by Richard L. Olsen
Detective Williams
Characters played by Grayson Howe
Detective Kitchens
Characters played by Jennifer Savidge
Mrs. Noble
Characters played by Michael Gohlke
Cameron Noble
Characters played by Laura Clifton
Eliza Noble
Characters played by Kristin Sutton
Cynthia Schubert
Characters played by John Walpole
Frank
Characters played by Melissa Rude
Anne Pine
Characters played by Mackinlee Waddell
Maggie Phillips
Characters played by Brad Sham
Sports Newscaster
Characters played by Sonya Van Sickle
Local Newscaster
Characters played by John McIntosh
Dentist
Characters played by Deana Ricks
Teacher
Characters played by Todd Terry
Pilot
Characters played by Chris Doubek
Psychiatrist
Characters played by Matthew Downs
Police Officer 1
Characters played by Taylor Hunt Wright
High Schooler
Characters played by Jon Michael Davis
Security Guard 1
Characters played by Adam Dietrich
Security Guard 2
Characters played by Troy Greger
Security Guard 3
Characters played by Brandon Thornton
Zack Hayes
Characters played by Jared Knight
Ryan Miller
Characters played by Alec Jhangiani
Lance
Characters played by Stephen Newby
Dentist Hand
Characters played by Thomas Wiederhold
Police Officer 2
Characters played by Jonathan Combs
Long Lost Friend
Characters played by Cindy Petrosky
Cougar
Characters played by Tiwong Smith
Andre the Giant 1
Characters played by Tswa Blue
Andre the Gaint 2
Characters played by Shawn Griffith
Neighbor
Characters played by Robert Grossman
Old Man on Scooter
Characters played by Abby Gregory
Gary's Supermodel Wife
Characters played by Andrew Armstrong III
Security Guard #3
Characters played by Ty Nathan Clark
Security Guard
Characters played by Kevin A. Green
Reunion Attendee
Characters played by Britanni Johnson
Homecoming date
Characters played by Krystal Wight Armstrong
Barista
Characters played by Steven Jeffers
Business Executive
Characters played by Amy Dawn Kear
Reunion Attendee
Characters played by Kristen Konzelman
Emily
Characters played by Melissa Wheeler
Reunion Attendee