Characters played by Abigail Mason
Lyddie Cottrell
Characters played by Lisa Pepper
Sarah Cain
Characters played by Elliott Gould
Bill Alexander
Characters played by Yolanda Stange
Norma
Characters played by Jennifer O'Dell
Madison Miller
Characters played by Tom Tate
Bryan Ford
Characters played by Carl Nelson
Waiter
Characters played by Micaela Nelligan
Lady Tourist
Characters played by Tom Markus
Bishop Stoltzfus
Characters played by Soren Fulton
Caleb Cottrell
Characters played by Danielle C. Ryan
Anna Mae Cottrell
Characters played by Tanner Maguire
Josiah Cottrell
Characters played by Bailee Madison
Hannah Cottrell
Characters played by Tess Harper
Miriam Esh
Characters played by John F. Cruz
Samuel King
Characters played by Phil Abrams
Charles Eberley
Characters played by Ian Reed Jones
Joseph King
Characters played by Monique Lanier
Ada King
Characters played by Max Whitaker
Sol King
Characters played by Annette Wright
Secretary
Characters played by Kalburt Dallof
Quigley
Characters played by Susan Dolan Stevens
Teacher
Characters played by Caitlin E.J. Meyer
Courtney
Characters played by Whitney Lee
Amanda
Characters played by Brittany Landon
Stacey
Characters played by Jeff Olsen
Coach Doyle
Characters played by Steve O'Neill
Fire Captain
Characters played by William Rubio
Fireman
Characters played by Barrett Ogden
Young Man
Characters played by Scott Christopher
Jerry Kitchel
Characters played by David Clennon
Homeless Man
Characters played by Tod Huntington
Police Officer #1
Characters played by K. Danor Gerald
Responding Officer
Characters played by Austin Sharette
Levi King
Characters played by Amanda Harker
Amish woman
Characters played by Jeff Olson
Coach Doyle
Characters played by Steve Anderson
Principal
Characters played by Alex Diaz
Zach
Characters played by Erin Empey-Baxter
Amish Mother
Characters played by Taylor Moulton
Amish Friend