Characters played by Lizzy Caplan
Sarah
Characters played by Alison Brie
Beth
Characters played by Martin Starr
Andrew
Characters played by Geoffrey Arend
Kevin
Characters played by Mark Webber
Jonathan
Characters played by Melonie Diaz
Isabelle
Characters played by Timothy Busfield
Benjie
Characters played by Gigi Bermingham
Mom
Characters played by Grant Harvey
Trevor
Characters played by Devin Barry
Soul Patch
Characters played by Jacob Womack
Jonathan's Friend
Characters played by Ray Conchado
Steppenwolf
Characters played by Lauren Nash
Cute Wolfbird Fan
Characters played by Kristin Slaysman
Michelle
Characters played by Robin Riker
Aunt Mary