Characters played by Cheryl Ladd
Mrs. Claus
Characters played by George Newbern
Thomas Reynolds
Characters played by Danny Woodburn
Eli
Characters played by Obba Babatundé
Mayor Denny
Characters played by Kaitlyn Maher
Sarah Reynolds
Characters played by Josh Feldman
Carter Reynolds
Characters played by Ali Hillis
Agnes Bright
Characters played by Bill Chott
Mr. Holman
Characters played by Paul Rae
Jeb Gibson
Characters played by Brian T. Finney
Sheriff Andy
Characters played by Ted Rooney
Mr. Miller
Characters played by Pat Finn
Santa Claus
Characters played by Tatiana Gudegast
Hope
Front Teeth Girl
Characters played by Aidan Gemme
Noble
Characters played by Genevieve Hannelius
Charity