Characters played by Tom Everett Scott
Dave Holden
Characters played by David Moscow
Tom Holden
Characters played by Cara Buono
Rachel
Characters played by David Lowery
Billy
Characters played by Denis O'Hare
Father
Characters played by Michael Kelly
Frankie
Characters played by Leo Burmester
Judge Perkins
Characters played by Tibor Feldman
Dr. Harry Fields
Characters played by James Murtaugh
Chief Bascomb
Characters played by Michael Angarano
Young Tom
Characters played by Peter Anthony Tambakis
Young Dave
Characters played by Ted Travelstead
Gas Attendant
Characters played by Marcia DeBonis
Sara
Characters played by Chris Cantwell
Mr. Taylor
Characters played by Andrew Van Dusen
Convenience Store Clerk