Characters played by Chris Miller
Narrator
Characters played by Stacey Davenport
Self - Assistant Commonwealth's Attorney
Characters played by Sylvia Adkins
Self - Amos' Daughter
Characters played by Lori Hugelmaier
Self - Lauren's Mom
Characters played by Jennifer Kliese
Self - Reporter
WKOW
Characters played by Sandy Liebl
Self - Joey's Best Friend
Characters played by Amy Major
Self - Susan's Daughter
Characters played by Amanda Lamb
Self - Crime Reporter
Characters played by Jamila Bey
Self - Journalist
Characters played by Rick Beach
Self - Friend
Characters played by Neil Frebowitz
Self - Lead Investigator
Characters played by Chelsea Crouch
Self - Joey's Sister
Characters played by Kristin Smith
Self - Television Reporter
Characters played by Josh Agner
Self - Lauren's Brother-in-law
Characters played by Dominique Vaile
Self - Matthew's Half Sister
Characters played by Shannon Taylor
Self - Commonwealth Attorney
Characters played by Pam Soberanes
Self - Susan's Co-worker
Characters played by Brad Richardson
Self - Prosecutor
Characters played by Phil Lakin
Self - Lead Investigator
Characters played by Amber Johnson
Self - Amos' Granddaughter
Characters played by Virginia Castro-Conroy
Self - Joey's Aunt
Characters played by Beth Agner
Self - Lauren's Sister
Characters played by Richard Ly
Self - Matthew's Friend
Characters played by Kris Vandehey
Self - Neighbour
Characters played by Michelle Coles
Self - Martre's Sister
Characters played by George Loydgren
Self - Detective
Characters played by Terry Jackson
Self - Detective
Characters played by Todd Benisch
Self - Dane County Sheriff's Office
Characters played by Travis Snyder
Self - Josephine County Sheriff's Office
Characters played by Ralph Wilson Jr.
Self - Defense Attorney
Characters played by Marqweisha Coles
Self - Martre's Sister
Characters played by Ashlyn Nicole Knight
Self - Martre's Girlfriend
Characters played by Cheryl Patty
Self - Dane County Sheriff's Office
Characters played by Todd Garvin
Self - Reporter
Characters played by Wendy Biddlecombe Agsar
Self - Crime Author
Characters played by Brooke Truett
Self - Matt's First Wife
Characters played by Lisa Turner
Self - Prosecutor
Characters played by Mark Aaron
Jeffrey Vogelsberg
Characters played by Scott Swope
Detective Todd Benisch
Characters played by Tom Myers
Det. Terry Jackson
Characters played by Richard Siegelman
Gary Goins
Characters played by Janae Palmer
Valerie
Characters played by Harvey Roberts
Lt. Phil Lakin
Characters played by Rachel Chelsea Foster
Lauren Hugelmaier Phelps
Characters played by Charles D. Clark
Detective
Characters played by Johnna Leary
Mourner
Characters played by Brayden Piccolo-Klein
Matthew Graville
Characters played by Cara Jaye
Dominique
Characters played by Sasha Allen
Michelle Coles
Characters played by Glenn Nelson
Detective Neil
Characters played by Daniel C. Davis
Matt
Characters played by Debbie Hartner
Melodye
Characters played by Jackie Diehl
Aubrey Goins
Characters played by David Cohen
Party Guest
Characters played by Meg Scanlon
Granddaughter
Characters played by Ryan Hinson
Detective Snyder
Characters played by Marc Goodman
Richard Crouch
Characters played by Misti Morningstar
Sylvia
Characters played by Judith Grannas
Laurie Hugelmaier
Characters played by Christopher Haley
Tyrone Coles
Characters played by Scott Gaver
Police Officer #1
Characters played by Joelle Denise
Denise Gay
Characters played by Hillaire Hess
Brianna Evans
Characters played by Greg Black
Lawyer
Characters played by Tom Fields
Dale Hugelmaier
Characters played by Addison da Silva
Randy
Characters played by Derek Quick
Mourner
Characters played by Patrick J. O'Neal
Police Officer
Characters played by Amy S. Young
Priest
Characters played by Joe La Marca
Amos
Characters played by Jadon Shamir
Martre Coles
Characters played by Daniel Braswell
Brett Hattenbrun
Characters played by Janine Oddis
Laura Robar
Characters played by Patti Purcell
Susan Goins
Characters played by Aarin Kennedy
Nehemiah James Evans