Characters played by Imari Williams
Narrator
Characters played by Justin Adams
Self - Journalist
Characters played by Wayne Adams
Self - Angela's Brother
Characters played by Christina Akinola
Self - Hillsboro Resident
Characters played by Cynthia Cindric
Self - Raynham Resident
Characters played by Brian Martin
Self - Fort Wayne Police
Characters played by Erin Runnion
Self - Samantha's Mom
Characters played by Lorraine Bucknum
Self - Hillsboro Resident
Characters played by Kimberly Dolan
Self - Raynham Resident
Characters played by Colleen Obergfell
Self - Fort Wayne Resident
Characters played by Evelyn Price
Self - Deerfield Beach Resident
Characters played by Kathleen Siliuta
Self - Neighbor
Characters played by Margie Story
Self - Carrie's School Friend
Characters played by Eric Apalategui
Self - Local Reporter
Characters played by Joanne Arruda
Self - Mary Lou's Mother
Characters played by Sally Berger
Self - Fort Wayne Resident
Characters played by Cecil Mitchell
Self - Dween Sr's Brother
Characters played by Lexi Siliuta
Self - Kathleen's Daughter
Characters played by Carolyn Tousignant
Self - Carrie's Mom
Characters played by Darrel Adams
Self - Angela's Brother
Characters played by Tony Arruda
Self - Mary Lou's Brother
Characters played by Jerry Bayless
Self - Crossing Guard
Characters played by Mary Kaisler
Self - Carrie's Aunt
Characters played by Michael O'Connell
Self - Detective
Characters played by Kristina Snyder
Self - April's Cousin
Characters played by Bernard Adams
Self - Angela's Father
Characters played by Robb Bauer
Self - Hillsboro Resident
Characters played by Karen Daley
Self - Mary Lou's Sister
Characters played by Christine Murray
Self - Homicide Sergeant
Characters played by Patrick Pajot
Self - Detective
Milwaukee PD
Characters played by Janet Tinsley
Self - April's Mother
Characters played by Joseph Arruda
Self - Mary Lou's Brother
Characters played by Pamela Bauer
Self - Hillsboro Resident
Characters played by Ali Ezzat
Self - Neighbor
Characters played by Andrew Gianino
Self - Deerfield Beach PD
Characters played by Angela Juarez
Self - Detective
Milwaukee PD
Characters played by Kevin Smith
Self - Indiana State Police
Characters played by Josephine Adams
Self - Angela's Mother
Characters played by Mark Carunchia
Self - Indiana State Police
Characters played by Deborah Case
Self - Hillsboro Resident
Characters played by Gary Jones
Self - Detective
Characters played by Helena McCoy
Self - Mary Lou's Friend
Characters played by Ronda Zarate
Self - Carrie's School Friend
Characters played by Lashelia Allen
Self - Cassandra's Sister
Characters played by John Klein
Self - Witness
Characters played by Margaret Kuether
Self - Carrie's Sister
Characters played by Patrick McCoy
Self - Mary Lou's Friend
Characters played by Scott Ryon
Self - Detective
Characters played by Michael Streed
Self - Police Sketch Artist
Characters played by Wilmer Delagrange
Self - Fort Wayne Resident
Characters played by Travis Gammage
Self - Deerfield Beach Resident
Characters played by Phyllis Grenier
Self - Family Friend
Characters played by Robert Hermann
Self - District Attorney
Characters played by Claire Luna
Self - Local Reporter
Characters played by Fred Tousignant
Self - Carrie's Stepdad
Characters played by Alan Alves
Self - Detective
Characters played by Jim Amormino
Self - Police Spokesperson
Characters played by Elvira Barraza
Self - Neighbor
Characters played by Bill Cochell
Self - Witness
Characters played by Linda Crouch
Self - Deerfield Beach Resident
Characters played by Clint Hetrick
Self - Indiana State Police
Characters played by Jose Barragan
Self - Local Resident
Characters played by Dave Bonaparte
Self - Police Officer
Characters played by Frank Ilarraza
Self - Cold Case Detective
Characters played by Ronald Louie
Self - Former Police Chief
Characters played by Conrad Nisiewicz
Self - Local Builder
Characters played by James Hensley
Self - Detective
Milwaukee PD
Characters played by Butch James
Self - Betty's Son
Characters played by Lou Pacheco
Self - Detective
Characters played by Lance Garth
Self - Prosecutor
Characters played by Timothy James
Self - Betty's Son
Characters played by Peter King
Self - Chief of Police
Characters played by Kyla McCay
Self - Betty's Granddaughter
Characters played by Sheila Berry
Self - Raynham Resident
Characters played by Mark Christy
Self - Detective Sergeant
Characters played by Leonard Darcell
Self - Suspect
Characters played by Paul Jordan
Self - Detective
Characters played by Christian Jae
Wayne Adams - Angela's Brother