Characters played by Jonathan Bennett
Jesus Christ
Characters played by Lea DeLaria
Tamara
Characters played by Lauren Tewes
Nina Ivanovna
Characters played by Dan Lauria
John
Characters played by Sophia Mitri Schloss
Mandy
Characters played by Sera Barbieri
Russian Lena
Characters played by Alycia Delmore
American Teacher
Characters played by Jule Johnson
Vova
Characters played by Annette Toutonghi
Sunday School Teacher
Characters played by James Grixoni
Young John
Characters played by Nick Sage Palmieri
Potato's Lover
Characters played by Alice Bridgforth
Bus Eavesdropper
Characters played by Darlene Sellers
John's First Wife
Characters played by Forrest Campbell
Fedia
Characters played by Nicole Santora
Carrie
Characters played by Tyler Bocock
American Potato
Characters played by Henry DiStefano
Little Boy John
Characters played by Amy Love
Sunday School Teacher
Characters played by Cameron Lee Price
Potato's Lover
Characters played by Drew Highlands
Potato's Lover
Characters played by Clyde Petersen
Delivery Man
Characters played by Marya Sea Kaminski
American Lena
Characters played by Hersh Powers
Russian Potato
Characters played by Jordan Iosua Taylor
Video Store Clerk
Characters played by Gus Lanza
Fantasy Husband
Characters played by Megan Grace Tuohy
Student
Characters played by Aaron Jin
Potato's Lover
Characters played by L. Gabriel Gonda
Fantasy Husband
Characters played by Eban Tracy
Dima
Characters played by Quinlan Corbett
Fantasy Husband
Characters played by Drew Cardillo
Fantasy Husband
Characters played by Max Christofferson
Timur
Characters played by Max Willoughby
Igor the Bully
Characters played by Justin Huertas
Bryan
Characters played by Dylan Smith
Potato's Lover
Characters played by Ruby Mimosa
John's 2nd Wife
Characters played by Jimmi Cook
Fantasy Husband - Cop
Characters played by Woody Shticks
V.I. Lenin
Potato's Lover
Characters played by Lady Rizo
Virgin Mary
Characters played by Stephen Hando
Prison Director
Characters played by Alexandra Tavares
John's Mother
Characters played by Samie Detzer
Video Store Clerk
Characters played by Brenden Williams
Fantasy Husband
Characters played by Sarah Rudinoff
Russian Teacher
Characters played by Davora Lindner
Barbara
Characters played by Dexter Morgenstern
Potato's Lover
Characters played by Ever Araucto
Young John's Friend
Characters played by Marvin Mecwan
Club Boy
Characters played by Elliot Gantner
Stepa
Characters played by Benjamin Camp
Classroom Photographer
Characters played by Bo Mellinger
Angel
Characters played by Alex Lichtenhan
Emo Student
Characters played by Carter Coonrod
Toddler Potato
Characters played by Adé Cônnére
Karaoke Performer
Characters played by Rebecca Davis
Female Pastor
Characters played by Nava Ruthfield
Girl Student
Characters played by Emmett Montgomery
Russian Orthodox Priest
Characters played by Paul Budraitis
Guard
Characters played by Paris Original
Angel
Characters played by Mandy Price
Polina
Characters played by Jesse Bell-Jones
Young Mother
Characters played by Sara Porkalob
Cheryl
Characters played by Tim Absalonson
Neighbor
Characters played by Michael Place
Potato's Father
Characters played by Chris Pitts
Cadet
Prisoner
Characters played by Samantha Detzer
Video Store Clerk
Characters played by Hisam Goueli
Fantasy Husband - Cowboy
Characters played by Luminous Pariah
Patrick
Characters played by Consuelo Aduviso
Nina
Characters played by Cynthia Linet
Bus Babushka
Characters played by Bailey Thiel
Potato's Lover
Characters played by Michael Monicatti
Young Prisoner
Characters played by Izzy Richter
Little Boy
Characters played by Dolores Rossman
Bus Babushka
Characters played by Devin Bannon
Prisoner
Characters played by Kamren Bell
John's Son
Characters played by Ro Yoon
Rose
Characters played by Alan Sutherland
Prisoner
Characters played by David Gehrman
Nina Ivanovna's Husband
Characters played by Opal Peachy
Sveta
Characters played by Randy Phillips
Potato's Lover