Characters played by Jennifer Nangle
Sasha (Segment "Sasha's Garage" "Helen Rogers" "Sasha's Story")
Characters played by Jack Hunter II
Henry
Characters played by Lara Jean Sullivan
Emma (Segment "Sasha's Story")
Characters played by Thomas Haley
Demonic Henry
Bill Rose (Segment "Sasha's Garage" "Helen Rogers")
Characters played by Michael O'Neal
Henry (Segment "Sasha's Garage")
Characters played by Charles Chudabala
Jimmy (Segment "Sasha's Garage")
Characters played by James Craigmiles
James (Segment "Autumn")
Characters played by Dordaneh Melody Leon
Skylar (segments "The Witch Murders" & "The Encounter")
Characters played by Tara Allen
Willow (segment "The Encounter")
Characters played by Steven 'Scuba Steve' Vasquez
Tony
Alien (segments "The Witch Murders" & "The Encounter")
Characters played by Bieke Baete
(segment "Interview of Emily Caterman")
Characters played by Phil Torres
Matt (segments "The Witch Murders" & "The Encounter")
Characters played by Jimmy Villarreal
Demon 2 (segment "The Witch Murders")
Characters played by Damien Anthony Vasquez
Demon 3 (segment "The Witch Murders")
Characters played by Joke Eyckerman
(segment "Interview of Emily Caterman")
Characters played by Ashley Lopez Delagarza
Laurren
Mad Witch (segments "The Witch Murders" & "The Encounter")
Characters played by Cody Tudor
Uncle Sol
Characters played by Clayton Harries
Demon 1 (segment "The Witch Murders")
Characters played by Sonya James
Victim (segment "The Witch Murders")
Characters played by Wesley Villeneuve
(segment "Interview of Emily Caterman")
Characters played by Nikki Vizcaino
Helena (Segment "Sasha's Story")
Characters played by Neiro Farias
Casey
Characters played by Vadim Pringels
(segment "Interview of Emily Caterman")
Characters played by Katie Keating
Helen Rogers (segment "Helen Rodgers")