Characters played by Soledad O'Brien
Self
Characters played by Pol Atteu
Self
Characters played by I. Elijah Baughman
CJ Stewart
Characters played by Carrie Bernans
Whitney Houston
Characters played by Alex Campbell Stein
FBI Agent
Characters played by Lenora Claire
Self
Characters played by Vicki Damante
Enthusiastic Fan
Characters played by Seth Di Marco
Rudy Mazzola
Characters played by Holgie Forrester
Cathy Davis
Characters played by Eric Gilbert
Self
Characters played by Eric Gilbert
Chippendales Reality Star 'Eric Gilbert'
Characters played by Susan Goldsmith
Self
Characters played by Katelyn Kay
Morgan (Guest-Star)
Characters played by Kiersten Kay
Peyton
Characters played by Candace Mayeron
Self
Characters played by Danny McFarland
Detective Smith
Characters played by Bruce Nahin
Self
Characters played by Chelsea Newman
Carrie
Characters played by Dan Peterson
Self
Characters played by Brooklyn Robinson
Anissa
Characters played by Rhonda Saunders
Self
Characters played by Patrik Simpson
Self
Characters played by Scott St. Blaze
Richard Ramirez