Most Likely to Murder Characters

Characters played by Madison McLaughlin

• Casey

• 
• 

Characters played by Heather McComb

• Laura

Characters played by Ava Allan

• Hailey

• 

Characters played by Trevor Stines

• Sean

• 

Characters played by Kara Royster

• Taylor

Characters played by Ingrid Rogers

• Deborah

Characters played by Fallon Smythe

• Daphne

Characters played by Brendan McCarthy

• Harlen

Characters played by Bayley Corman

• Reagan

• 
• 

Characters played by Ashlee Füss

• Clair

Characters played by Joseph Lim Kim

• Mr. Lavalier

Characters played by Peter Donahue

• Vance

Characters played by Taylor LeBaugh

• Kyle

Characters played by Olivia Handwerk

• Hiker