Characters played by H. Jon Benjamin
Satan
Special Father #1
Characters played by Melissa Bardin Galsky
Lucy
Becky
The Devil's Advocate
Becky
Characters played by Jon Glaser
DJ Jesus
Characters played by Sam Seder
Special Father #2
The Senator
Characters played by Eugene Mirman
Special Sister
Characters played by Todd Barry
Brian the Altar Boy
Catholic School Girl
Cult Member
Ethan
Eyeball Salesman
Movie Producer
Security Guard
Tad Whitehead
Various
Characters played by Jessi Klein
Lucy