Characters played by Christina Ricci
Lizzie Borden
Characters played by Clea DuVall
Emma Borden
Characters played by Gregg Henry
Hosea Knowlton
Characters played by Stephen McHattie
Andrew Borden
Characters played by Shawn Doyle
Marshall Hilliard
Characters played by Sara Botsford
Abby Morse Borden
Characters played by Hannah Emily Anderson
Bridget Sullivan
Characters played by Andrea Runge
Alice Russell
Characters played by Billy Campbell
Andrew Jennings
Characters played by Brett Donahue
Marshall Fleet
Characters played by Jeremy Akerman
Judge Blaidsell
Characters played by John Dunsworth
Dr. Bowen
Characters played by Gary Levert
Mayor Coughlin
Characters played by John Maclaren
Rev. Edwin A. Buck
Characters played by Andrew Gillies
Judge Mason
Characters played by Andrew Bush
Medical Examiner
Characters played by Glenn Lefchak
Eli Bence
Characters played by Brian Downey
Jury Foreman
Characters played by Jason Chemij
Soldier Mike
Characters played by Kirstin Howell
Susan Smith
Characters played by Andria Wilson Mirza
Nance O'Neill
Characters played by Onofre Pereria
Eddie Sousa
Characters played by Jennifer Kydd
Socialite
Characters played by Mark Owen
Bailiff
Characters played by Gareth Meagher
Businessman Henry
Characters played by John O'Keefe
Businessman William
Characters played by Ciarán MacGillivray
Stanley Jeffries
Characters played by Jeremy Webb
Police Clerk
Characters played by Kevin Kincaid
Reporter #1
Characters played by Kyle Mitchell
Reporter #2
Characters played by Kristin Langille
Friend
Characters played by Vikki Humphrey
Well Dressed Woman
Characters played by Lydia Stevens
Bertha Manchester
Characters played by Jarah Theriault
Jump-Rope Girl #1
Characters played by Ciana Dickie
Jump-Rope Girl #2
Characters played by Amber Patey
Jump-Rope Girl #3
Characters played by Suzie Steen
Abby Borden
Characters played by Emmy DeOliveira
Girl #2
Characters played by Craig Layton
Gallery Member
Characters played by Rebecca Catherine Struthers
Girl