Characters played by Aubrey Plaza
Laura
Characters played by Lucy DeVito
Chrissy
Characters played by Danny DeVito
Satan
Characters played by Mel Forrest
Camry
Choochies
Improvisor Creature
Janitor
Kid
Party Goer
Whole Crowd
Characters played by Darcy Fowler
Sexy Harpy
Choochies
Lunch Lady
Miss Rainy
Mrs. Lalish
Normal Kid
Whole Crowd
Wife
Characters played by Seth Kirschner
Erwin
Beast Guards
Choochies
Craig
Mustache Bully
Party Goer
Pope
Townsperson
Whole Crowd
Characters played by Phil LaMarr
Principal Dawkins
Big Strong Man
Male Newscaster
Middle Aged DJ
Real Estate Inspector
Slick Naked Businessman
Townsperson
Whole Crowd
Characters played by Charlie McWade
Snake with Arms
Businessman
Choochies
Creature Open Mic Host
Crony
Drunk Guy
Man in Overalls
Mr. Lalish
Characters played by Laci Mosley
iCal
Brank
Choochies
Librarian
Party Goer
Random Student
Townsperson
Whole Crowd
Characters played by Kieran Valla
Choochies
Generic Businessman
Normal Kid #2
Party Goer
Robber
Slimm Timm
Whole Crowd
Wicker Truck Driver
Characters played by Lennon Parham
Darlene
Characters played by Eugene Cordero
Bennigan
Characters played by Annie Worden
Careless Man
Choochies
Female Newscaster
Little Puppet Boy
Peter
Townsperson
Vicious Monster
Characters played by Michael Shannon
Unshaven Man
Characters played by Ali Ahn
Arabella
Characters played by Keith Powell
Bobby
Father Cleare
Toby
Whole Crowd
Characters played by Juan Francisco Villa
Mayor
Characters played by William Jackson Harper
Jimmy
Characters played by Sam Richardson
Asmodeus
Characters played by D.J. 'Shangela' Pierce
Queen Inichoochiama
Characters played by Patrick Wilson
Everett
Characters played by Arnold Schwarzenegger
Game Show Host
Characters played by Gary Richardson
Ogbert
Characters played by Kari Wahlgren
Party Goer