Characters played by Isabela Merced
Julie
Characters played by Shameik Moore
Stuart
Characters played by Odeya Rush
Addie
Characters played by Liv Hewson
Dorrie
Characters played by Mitchell Hope
Tobin
Characters played by Kiernan Shipka
Angie
Characters played by Matthew Noszka
JP
Characters played by Jacob Batalon
Keon
Characters played by Miles Robbins
Billy
Characters played by Joan Cusack
Tin Foil Woman
Characters played by Anna Akana
Kerry
Characters played by Genevieve DeGraves
Jessica
Characters played by Rebecca Ablack
Anisha
Characters played by Christina de la Cruz
Connie
Characters played by Briar Nolet
Lisa
Characters played by Shantel Angela Vailloo
Zoe
Characters played by Andrea de Oliveira
Debbie
Characters played by Victor Rivers
Pops
Characters played by D'Arcy Carden
Kira
Characters played by Jon Champagne
Chad Reston
Characters played by Jamie Champagne
Pete Reston
Characters played by Mason Gooding
Jeb
Characters played by Hallea Jones
Madison
Characters played by Journey Christine
Lo
Characters played by Von Flores
Mr. Bernal
Characters played by Rodrigo Fernandez-Stoll
Stallholder
Characters played by Amy Stewart
Woman on Train
Characters played by Tal Zimerman
Male Customer
Characters played by Karen Waddell
Reverend
Characters played by Raevv'n Leedham
Winter Solstice Woman
Characters played by Eric Weinthal
Rabbi
Characters played by Morrissa Nicole
Kwanza Woman
Characters played by David Cotton
Jesus
Characters played by Biden Hall
Wiseman #1
Characters played by Scott Hurst
Wiseman #2
Characters played by Bren Eastcott
Goddess Lakshmi #1
Characters played by Tahirih Vejdani
Goddess Lakshmi #2
Characters played by Angelica Alejandro
Keon's Mother
Characters played by Chris Chinchilla
Caroler #2
Characters played by Felicia Simone
Waffletown Waitress