Characters played by Hilarie Burton
Annie
Characters played by Gabriel Hogan
John
Characters played by Tim Matheson
Reginald Buckley
Characters played by Lola Flanery
Madison
Characters played by Jayne Eastwood
Mrs. Claus
Characters played by Derek McGrath
Santa
Characters played by K. Trevor Wilson
Randy
Characters played by James Wallis
Tony
Characters played by Eric Woolfe
Joey
Characters played by Mike Bell
Hotel Desk Clerk
Characters played by Darrin Baker
Eliot Shulwater
Characters played by Leanne Poirier Greenfield
Tanya Leland
Characters played by Michael Vincent Dagostino
Fred
Characters played by Gabriel Levac
Little Boy
Characters played by Nick Boegel
Badger
Characters played by Lewis Hodgson
Sheriff Jim
Characters played by Alyssa Piazza
Elf
Characters played by Skyler Shaganash
Boy in Hotel