Characters played by Rachel Mills
Self - Researcher
Characters played by Joshua Zeman
Self - Writer
Director
Cropsey
Characters played by Stephen Winick
Self - American Folklife Center
Library of Congress
Characters played by James Presley
Self - Author
A Town in Terror
Characters played by Casey Roberts
Self - Media Manager at Texas A&M
Texarkana
Characters played by Bill Ellis
Self - Professor Emeritus
Penn State
Characters played by Robby Robertson
Self - Director
Texarkana Parks and Rec
Characters played by Mark Bledsoe
Self - Phantom Expert
Characters played by Jereme Kennington
Self - Local Phantom Expert
Characters played by Joel Best
Self - Sociologist
University of Delaware
Characters played by Ed Goad
Self - Ret. Lt. Pasadena Police Dept.
Characters played by Craig Smyser
Self - Former Reporter
Houston Chronicle
Characters played by Mike Hinton
Self - Former Asst. District Attorney
Characters played by David Crump
Self - Professor of Law
University of Houston
Characters played by Carol Haley Holt
Self - Friend of Janett Christman
Characters played by Mary Beth Brown
Self - Local Historian
Characters played by Joan Sorrels
Self - Local Historian
Characters played by Peter Brendt
Self - Profiler
Kansas City
Characters played by Joe Durwin
Self - Author
'The Trickster'
Characters played by Isaiah Thompson
Self - Local Reporter
Characters played by Bob Egan
Self - Former Prosecutor on the Gacy Case
Characters played by Jason Moran
Self - Cook County Detective
Characters played by Ken Melvoin-Berg
Self - Clown Historian
Characters played by Betty Jo Booker
Self - Murder Victim
Characters played by Janett Christman
Self - Murder Victim
Characters played by Richard L. Griffin
Self - Murder Victim
Characters played by Marylou Jenkins
Self - Murder Victim
Characters played by Paul Martin
Self - Murder Victim
Characters played by Polly Ann Moore
Self - Murder Victim
Characters played by Floyd Cochran
Self - Executed Man
Characters played by Timothy O'Bryan
Self - Murder Victim
Characters played by Robert Mueller
Self - Suspected Murderer
Characters played by Ronald Clark O'Bryan
Self - Candy Man Killer
Characters played by Youell Swinney
Self - Phantom Killer Suspect
Characters played by Jake Bradford
Self - Rapist
Characters played by Helen Pfeil
Self - Handed Out Contaminated Halloween Candy
Characters played by David Brinkley
Self - Newscaster
Characters played by Tom Brokaw
Self - Newscaster
Characters played by John Chancellor
Self - Newscaster
Characters played by Connie Chung
Self - Newscaster
Characters played by Phil Donahue
Self - Host
The Phil Donahue Show
Characters played by Harry Reasoner
Self - Newscaster
Characters played by Susan Starnes
Self - Reporter
Characters played by Charles Bessett
Self - Parent
Characters played by Joe Coyle
Self - Survivor
Hagenbeck-Wallace Circus Train Crash
Characters played by John Wayne Gacy
Self - Serial Killer
Characters played by Rick Hartley
Self - Huntsville Prison Spokesman
Characters played by James Holmes
Self - Aurora
Colorado Mass Shooter
Characters played by Joyce Nelson
Self - New Sullivan Elementary School
Characters played by Ashley Stanfill
Self - Nextcare Urgent Care
Characters played by Gregory Palmer
Self - Cameraman