Characters played by Olivia Jade
Paige Chilling
Characters played by Ali Chappell
Blossom
Characters played by Avery Crumley
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Jimmy Pressley
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Michael Novelli
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Albie Robles
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Jamie Robert MacDougall
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Matthew Mark Hunter
Benny Hunter
Bozo
Characters played by John Catheline
Anthony Lynn
Characters played by Troy Oelke
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Tim Novotny
Creepy Elf
Characters played by Dale Niehaus
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Harper Holmes
April Lynn
Characters played by B.J. Halsall
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Kellen DeRuy
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Larry DiBartolomeo
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Krista Dotson
Mary Lynn
Characters played by Hilda Ivette Rodriguez
Doll
Characters played by Rudy Ledbetter
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Scott E. Brosius
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Jude Vivona
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Mike Doyle
Killer Christmas Tree
Characters played by Christopher Avant
Clank
Characters played by Katelyn M. Allen
Jenny Lynn
Characters played by Tyler Craig
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Buddy Candela
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Samantha McLarty
Doll
Characters played by Audrey O'Bryon
Dolly
Characters played by Bozo
Bozo
Characters played by Erin Keuter Laughlin
Doll
Characters played by Madison Hudak
Doll
Characters played by Kayla Royko
Valerie Jones
Characters played by Brennan Shirley
Christian
Characters played by Nathan Smith
Demon Present
Characters played by Thomas Eugene Otterman
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by R.J. Koker
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Karey Miller
Doll
Characters played by Luke Wood
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Nick Matthew
Robert Jones
Characters played by Eric Wright Lee
Carols Rivers
Characters played by Leilah Chapanar
Young Valeire
Characters played by Wysteria Shaw
Doll
Characters played by Dusty Riso
Demon Present
Characters played by William Irving Grossman
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Fady Makary
Donnie Drake
Characters played by Sharon Scott Brooking
Doll
Characters played by Jason Davis
Teddy
Characters played by Michelle Rose
Amber Jones
Characters played by Bobby Holstein
Stuffed Animal
Characters played by Chris Wiggins
Nick Hunt
Characters played by Jason Davis
Teddy
Characters played by Angie Rovnyak
Demon Present