Characters played by Vincent Cusimano
Sheriff Wexler
Characters played by Eddie T. Davies
Troy Evans
Characters played by Danielle Desecki
Kelly Spalina
Characters played by Naresh Kavuri
Eric Kyser's Bandmate
Characters played by Kristen Renton
Detective Marcotte
Characters played by Bruce Spielbauer
Father Dan
Characters played by Kayla Swift
Detective Jennifer Mueller
Characters played by Justin Thaler
Cult Member
Characters played by Matt Ukena
Eric Kyser
Characters played by Dane Valerio
Art Spallina
Characters played by Carly Woods
Donna Loewy