Characters played by Ikechukwu Ufomadu
Inspector Ike
Characters played by Matt Barats
Harry Newcombe
Characters played by Ana Fabrega
Deputy Hawthorne
Characters played by Grace Rex
Jan
Characters played by John Early
Chip Conrad
Characters played by Aparna Nancherla
Fran
Characters played by Anthony Oberbeck
Deputy Dinardo
Characters played by Jessica Damouni
Rita Conrad
Characters played by Dorothi Fox
Esther
Characters played by Alex Goldberg
Al
Characters played by River L. Ramirez
Loretta
Characters played by Stavros Halkias
Confused Waiter for 'Al's Pizza'
Characters played by Dan Arnes
Wealthy Criminal
Characters played by Rhys Grady
Christmas Criminal
Characters played by Amy Zimmer
Magician Criminal
Characters played by Tynan DeLong
Phantom of the Opera
Characters played by Leah Motzkin
Rockette
Characters played by Carly Lovejoy
Rockette
Characters played by Sarah Madden
Rockette
Characters played by Colin Burgess
Stage Actor
Characters played by Eudora Peterson
Stage Actor
Characters played by Jen Goma
Stage Actor
Characters played by Caroline Yost
Stage Actor
Characters played by Alexandra Tatarsky
Mime
Characters played by Ryan McGlade
Kabuki Mask Man