Characters played by Liev Schreiber
Drew Hagel
Characters played by Marisa Tomei
Carrie Manning
Characters played by Peter Sarsgaard
Quint Manning
Characters played by Maya Hawke
Shannon Hagel
Characters played by Alex Wolff
Ian Warfield
Characters played by Betty Gabriel
Ronnie Hagel
Characters played by Aasif Mandvi
Godeep
Characters played by Paul Sparks
Jon
Characters played by Fred Hechinger
Jamie Manning
Characters played by John Ventimiglia
David
Characters played by Dominic Colón
Roberto Jarvis
Characters played by James Waterston
Andy
Characters played by Fredric Lehne
Detective Flowers
Characters played by Daryl Edwards
Detective Gore
Characters played by Greta Quispe
Nanny