Characters played by Kerry Bishé
Janet
Characters played by Joel McHale
Tom
Characters played by Al Madrigal
Arthur
Characters played by Natalie Zea
Karen
Characters played by Paul Scheer
Val
Characters played by Billie Wolff
Waitress
Characters played by Stephen Root
Goodman
Characters played by Natalie Morales
Patricia
Characters played by Jon Daly
Donald
Characters played by Kirby Howell-Baptiste
Maude
Characters played by Shannon Woodward
Carla
Characters played by Charlyne Yi
Gretel
Characters played by Breckin Meyer
Richard
Characters played by Brea Grant
Cashier