Characters played by Mary Ellen Ashley
Sister Mary Theresa Shay
Characters played by Nick Choksi
Punjab O'Shaughnessy
Characters played by Denise Dumper
Gwendolyn Thompson
Characters played by Brandon Espinoza
Jock
Characters played by Meghann Fahy
Lila Morgan
Characters played by Jenna Leigh Green
Waitress
Characters played by Olli Haaskivi
Henry
Characters played by Eliana Kwartler
The Grim Reaper
Characters played by Lauren Lukacek
Punjab's Assistant
Characters played by Shina Ann Morris
Octavianna White
Characters played by Amelia Pedlow
Virginia Stark
Characters played by Monica Raymund
Dialect Tape
Characters played by Jason Michael Snow
James
Characters played by Alex Wyse
Dalton Gummer